gold star for USAHOF

Top 50 Pittsburgh Steelers

There are many that feel that the Pittsburgh Steelers really did not begin until the 1970s, but of course, that isn't true.

The origin of the Steelers dates all the way back in 1933, and they are the seventh oldest NFL franchise in existence.  They made the playoffs in 1947, but that was the only time they made it to a post-season from 1933 to 1971.  The Steelers would then become the power of the AFC, winning four Super Bowls in the 1970s, primarily on the strength of their potent "Steel Curtain" defense.

Their 70s success made them one of the most popular teams in the game, a status that they maintain today.  Pittsburgh never had another dynasty, but they did have success winning two more Super Bowls this millennium, giving them six, which is tied with the New England Patriots for the most.


Note: Football lists are based on an amalgamation of tenure, traditional statistics, advanced statistics, playoff statistics, and post-season accolades.

This list is active until the end of the 2024 Season.

Many lists place “Mean” Joe Greene at the top of the Pittsburgh Steelers’ all-time rankings, and the choice can look automatic from a distance. The reality is more complicated. The franchise has produced a long line of Hall of Fame players, and several of them could reasonably claim the top spot. Still, when the question turns to who best embodies…
The Pittsburgh Steelers already possessed a formidable defense when they selected Jack Lambert in the second round of the 1974 draft. He had been the Mid-American Conference Defensive Player of the Year two seasons earlier at Kent State, and he arrived with the physical style and instincts the team needed at middle linebacker. Lambert became the starting middle linebacker early…
Mike Webster was a fifth-round pick out of Wisconsin in 1974, and he spent his first two seasons contributing on special teams while also seeing time at center and guard. The Steelers were already on their way to the first two Super Bowl wins of the decade, and Webster’s work in those early years was limited but useful. He was…
Franco Harris remains the Pittsburgh Steelers’ all-time leading rusher, and every other running back in franchise history lines up behind him. He arrived in 1972 as a first-round pick out of Penn State, a short trip from Pittsburgh, and he immediately became the focal point of the offense. As a rookie he rushed for 1,055 yards and 10 touchdowns, earned…
A 1971 Second Round Pick from Penn State, Jack Ham brought a speed dynamic to the Linebacking corps of the Pittsburgh Steelers.
Finally, we have a player who predated their 1970s Super Bowl era with Ernie Stautner, one of the toughest men from the toughest period of the toughest sport.
If you got past the Steel Curtain, you were not that lucky.  You had Mel Blount to contend with.
Rod Woodson may not have won a Super Bowl with the Pittsburgh Steelers, unlike some of the other elite Defensive Backs on this list, but he was, without a doubt, the best player regardless of position for the team for nearly a decade.
In terms of recent popularity, it is hard to come up with a player who exceeds Troy Polamalu.
The 2004 NFL Draft yielded Eli Manning and Philip Rivers, but it was Ben Roethlisberger, the third QB taken, who won the Super Bowl first.
When you are the younger brother of J.J. Watt, a large shadow is cast over you.  T.J. Watt has done a great job escaping it.
Say what you want about how the help that Terry Bradshaw had with the Steel Curtain defense and Franco Harris in the backfield, but no Quarterback wins four Super Bowls without being an excellent player.
A late First Round Pick from LSU, Alan Faneca became precisely the Left Tackle that the Pittsburgh Steelers hoped he would be.
An All-American and Rose Bowl winner at Ohio State, Cameron Heyward was taken 31st overall in the 2011 Draft, but it has been in the last three years where he has shone and earned a spot on this list. 
Antonio Brown wasn’t taken until the Sixth Round of the 2010 Draft, but the Wide Receiver from Central Michigan would become one of the best Wide Receivers of the decade.
James Harrison's road to professional football stardom with the Steelers was full of potholes.
With ten members of the 1970’s Pittsburgh Steelers already in the Football Hall of Fame, you would think that the team that won four Super Bowls in that decade would be sufficiently represented in Canton.  Some have said that they have the right amount, but the wrong representatives.  Those people point to L.C. Greenwood as the omission.