The Hall of Fame promises to be a crowded place for quarterbacks in the AFC in 20 years if the current crop of players continue to astound and develop. The 2022 season has highlighted the rise of brilliant young quarterbacks, so much so that Patrick Mahomes, at the age of 27, is the elder statesman of the group. The Kansas City Chiefs player has already put forward an impressive resume for his Hall of Fame credentials. He's already won one Super Bowl and reached another in the first five years of his career.
The Chiefs are once again backed as one of the leading contenders in the odds to win the Super Bowl. A second Vince Lombardi Trophy would all but ensure that Mahomes will be donning a yellow jacket at the end of his career. However, there will be intense competition along the way due to the quality of quarterbacks and teams in the AFC Conference alone. That will make Canton, Ohio a crowded place should they all opt to retire at the same time. It will also make for an enthralling 20 years of AFC action, bringing back memories of the conference when it was at its best, a time when Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Philip Rivers, Ben Roethlisberger and others battled it out to reach the Super Bowl.
The new era looks even more exciting.
Mahomes has almost punched his ticket to Canton and, if he opted to retire tomorrow, there would be few doubters that would deny him a place in the Hall of Fame. He has been electric on the field since replacing Alex Smith in his sophomore season. Mahomes appears to be all set to win his second MVP after a brilliant 2022 season in which he propelled the Chiefs to the number one seed, notably without Tyreek Hill.
That was a major challenge for Mahomes, but he passed with flying colors, connecting with his new wideouts. With Travis Kelce closer to the end of his career than the start, he will have to continue to develop players around him. Mahomes will now aim to reach his third Super Bowl to banish memories of his side’s defeat to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in the 2020 campaign.
Allen and Mahomes played out a thrilling Divisional Round matchup last season. Mahomes’ brilliance in the final 13 seconds tied the game before the Buffalo Bills were beaten in overtime to deny them a second-straight AFC Championship appearance. Allen has been incredible once again this season, displaying maturity and leadership as well as having every throw in the book. He alone will give the Bills a fighting chance in the AFC every year.
Even after Tom Brady's exit, it was not easy to dethrone the New England Patriots at the top of the AFC East. But Allen and Buffalo are now kings of the East and will now look to transfer that dominance to the AFC. He and his team just need to raise their levels in the big games, because only then can Allen be considered one of the greats.
Burrow well and truly announced his arrival lasts season with a brilliant run to knock off the Chiefs away at the AFC Championship Game. The Bengals were not quite ready to win the Super Bowl, narrowly losing out to the Los Angeles Rams. However, Burrow and his team are a confident bunch and, with Joe Cool as quarterback, will be contenders every year.
Burrow has earned comparisons to Brady when it comes to his demeanor on the field. He always seems to make clutch throws with pinpoint accuracy when it matters the most. Burrow doesn’t have the wow plays of Mahomes and Allen, but he's downright clinical when required. If the Bengals can keep him upright and injury-free, Cincinnati will be a perennial Super Bowl contender.
Burrow has the personality and drive to win multiple crowns. Although he'd be doing very well to ever match Brady, he is certainly capable of winning one or two.
In the early stages of the 2022 seasons there were fears that Lawrence was trending towards being a bust. He endured a miserable rookie campaign, which was entirely the fault of former head coach Urban Meyer, who failed to last the term with the Jacksonville Jaguars. Doug Pederson’s arrival promised stability and the chance for Lawrence to develop. It didn’t appear to go that way after a poor performance in a loss to the Denver Broncos.
But from then on Lawrence flicked the switch and was sensational down the stretch, guiding his team to seven victories in nine games. The Jags won the AFC South for the first time since 2017 and it could well be the start of an era of dominance. Lawrence’s performances were made all the more impressive considering the lack of talent around him. If the Jags get him some top-tier receivers, he will flourish in Florida.
Herbert is the other quarterback in the AFC West that has all the tools, but has not quite put it all together yet. He won Rookie of the Year ahead of Burrow and Tua Tagovailoa in 2020, but he has not been able to take the next step yet, despite making the post-season for the first time in 2022. The Los Angeles Chargers have always had a string of bad luck and bad decision-making that has held them back. They cannot afford to let that happen to Herbert as it did his predecessor Rivers.
Herbert has all the talent in the world and skills to match Mahomes, Allen and Burrow. He just needs to settle in with a composed coach that will allow him to thrive in the big moments. Herbert could be the answer to the Chargers’ longstanding playoff woes.
Lamar Jackson could have been on the same trajectory as the other quarterbacks, but injuries and a lack of post-season form has stalled his progress. Renowned for his running ability, he has developed as a passer, making him a dual-threat quarterback. Until he can resolve his injury woes once and for all, he and the Baltimore Ravens are going nowhere.
It’s the same story for Tua and the Miami Dolphins. After two poor seasons, head coach Mike McDaniel appeared to unlock Tua's potential. Tua connected with Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle to devastating effect to propel Miami towards the number one seed in the AFC. However, he sustained two concussions over the course of the season, the second one ruling him out of the final three games of the campaign. That is a huge concern for the Dolphins moving forward, and could end a bright career.
Kenley Jansen’s career in Los Angeles as a defensive specialist from Curaçao, but his journey took a historic turn when the organization converted him from a catcher into a relief pitcher in 2009. Armed with a natural, cut-fastball that defied physics, he moved through the system with lightning speed. Across 12 seasons in Chavez Ravine, he evolved into the most prolific "door-shutter" in the history of the franchise
Since his debut in 2010, Jansen elevated his consistency and became the full-time closer by 2012. He relied on a specialized cutter, similar to Mariano Rivera's signature pitch, to effectively strike out batters and achieve remarkable strikeout numbers. By 2015, he reached an exceptional level of efficiency, maintaining a WHIP below 0.800 for four consecutive years. During this period, he achieved an extraordinary 10.00 SO/BB ratio on two occasions.
Between 2016 and 2017, he authored a remarkable campaign in '17, finishing fifth in the Cy Young voting. He led the National League with 41 saves and posted a tiny 1.32 ERA. As a dominant force in late innings, he received back-to-back Trevor Hoffman NL Reliever of the Year Awards and was named the Sporting News Reliever of the Year both seasons. During this period, he became a regular participant in the Midsummer Classic, earning three straight All-Star selections and establishing himself as the top high-leverage reliever in the Senior Circuit.
After years of postseason heartbreak, Jansen served as a primary engine for the squad that finally captured the World Series title. He finalized his residency in Blue following the 2021 season, departing for Atlanta as the franchise’s all-time saves leader with 350.
Jansen compiled 350 saves, a 2.37 ERA, and 1,022 strikeouts as a Dodger.
Whit Wyatt didn't merely find renewed success in Brooklyn; he essentially crafted a new career. By the time he joined the Dodgers in 1939, he was 30 years old and was largely viewed as a discarded player from the American League, having spent the previous year in the minor leagues. However, while three other teams saw him as finished, Brooklyn recognized him as an untapped ace.
After a decade of obscurity, he reached Ebbets Field and instantly elevated his play, earning four straight All-Star selections from 1939 to 1942. He displayed a sudden, localized dominance that peaked during the landmark 1941 season. That year, Wyatt was not just a contributor but a standout. He led the league with 22 wins and five shutouts, while his advanced metrics, leading the NL in FIP (2.44), WHIP (1.058), and SO/BB (2.15), established him as the clear staff leader. He finished third in MVP voting, a placement that would likely have secured a Cy Young award if the trophy had been available.
Wyatt's brilliance propelled the Dodgers to the 1941 pennant, ending a 21-year drought. He provided high-leverage efficiency, notably outdueling the Yankees in Game 2 of the World Series for Brooklyn's only win. He remained a key part of the rotation during the early war years, with 18 wins in 1942 and 14 in 1943, earning MVP votes both seasons. His mound command defied age, showing improvement as the stakes increased.
In 1944, as the heavy workload and his mid-thirties began to take their toll, the organization finalized a deal to sell his contract to the Phillies, but it lasted only 10 games before Wyatt called it a career.
Wyatt had an ERA of 2.86 with an 80-46 Record with Brooklyn. That might be 80 more Wins than many baseball writers thought he would do.
After a cup of coffee with the St. Louis Browns in 1911, Jeff Pfeffer made it to Brooklyn in 1913, where the righthander became one of the most durable arms of the Deadball Era.
Pfeffer reached an absolute summit of efficiency in 1914. He authored a brilliant 23-12 record with a 1.97 ERA over 315 innings, a performance that surely would have made him the Rookie of the Year had the award existed then. He also had a career-high 135 strikeouts
Pfeffer reached his peak during the memorable 1916 season. He delivered an incredible performance, winning 25 games with a fantastic 1.92 ERA as the Robins proudly took the National League crown. He was a key player on the team, finishing among the top five in wins and innings pitched, and he proved to be a versatile asset during the postseason. In the 1916 World Series against the Boston Red Sox, he made a crucial save in Game 3 and pitched a tough seven innings in the Game 5 finale. Although the Robins fell short in the series, Pfeffer’s stellar statistics from 1914 to 1916—67 wins and a remarkably low ERA, stand out as one of the most impressive three-year stretches in franchise history.
Pfeffer’s baseball journey took an unexpected pause in 1918 when he enlisted in the U.S. Navy during World War I. When he returned in 1919, he scored a fresh wave of success, recording two consecutive 16-win seasons and playing a key role in helping Brooklyn clinch another pennant in 1920. However, after facing some challenges at the start of the 1921 season, the team decided to trade him to the St. Louis Cardinals.
With the Robins, Pfeffer had a 2.31 ERA with a record of 113- 80.