Arriving in Minnesota via the Rule 5 Draft, Johan Santana was a left-hander from Venezuela with a high-velocity fastball and a changeup that many considered the most devastating pitch of the era.
Santana spent his first three years as a mainstay in the bullpen and a spot starter, but everything changed dramatically in the second half of 2004. He delivered an incredible stretch, going 13-0 with a 1.21 ERA after the All-Star break, earning his first Cy Young Award by a unanimous vote. He mastered the league, leading the AL in strikeouts (265), ERA (2.61), and WHIP (0.92). This period proved he was an elite talent capable of shutting down baseball's most dangerous offenses, establishing himself as one of the best in the game.
Santana achieved a historic summit between 2005 and 2006, demonstrating a level of consistency that established him as the most sought-after pitcher in the league. In 2006, he attained the rare Pitching Triple Crown, leading the league in wins (19), ERA (2.77), and strikeouts (245), thus earning his second unanimous Cy Young Award. Although he "only" finished third in the 2005 voting, a result that remains subject to debate among sabermetricians, he demonstrated a relentless capacity to produce swings and misses, leading all Major League Baseball pitchers in strikeouts for three consecutive seasons. During this period of peak performance, he was a master tactician who consistently gave the Minnesota Twins a high probability of victory about every five days.
Before the 2008 season, with free agency looming and the Twins unable to meet his market value, the organization initiated a blockbuster trade, sending him to the New York Mets in exchange for a four-prospect package that included Carlos Gómez. With Minnesota, Santana compiled a 93-44 record, a 3.22 ERA, and 1,381 strikeouts, and in 2018, he took his rightful spot in the Twins Hall of Fame.
In February 2008, the Mets made a historic, franchise-changing trade with the Minnesota Twins, who sent their star left-hander Johan Santana east in exchange for Carlos Gómez, Philip Humber, Deolis Guerra, and Kevin Mulvey. The Mets quickly signed Santana to a groundbreaking six-year, $137.5 million deal, making him the highest-paid pitcher in baseball at that time. Although many historians associate his peak dominance mainly with his years in Minnesota, it's a significant oversight to ignore the incredible, impactful performances he delivered for New York before his arm injuries.
Santana delivered an outstanding debut in 2008, pitching on short rest at the end of the season and totaling a career-high 234.1 innings. That summer, he reached a peak performance by going 16-7, winning the Major League ERA title with a remarkable 2.53, and setting a franchise record for strikeouts by a left-hander with 206. He finished third in the NL Cy Young voting. Interestingly, his overall 3.18 ERA during his time with the Mets is slightly lower than his legendary years with the Twins, indicating his elite ability to prevent runs.
Severe shoulder injuries and surgeries severely impacted Santana's athletic performance, causing him to miss the entire 2011 and 2013 seasons. Despite these setbacks, he achieved legendary status in franchise history through a remarkable, high-stakes game. On June 1, 2012, after a tough comeback, he took the mound at Citi Field against the St. Louis Cardinals. Ignoring pitch count limits, he dedicated himself completely, throwing 134 intense pitches to secure the first official no-hitter in New York Mets history.
That would be his last great moment in baseball, as the injuries became too much and he retired in 2014 after missing the 2013 campaign. With the Mets, Santana had a 46-34 record.
For a seven-year period, Johan Santana was regarded as one of the top Pitchers in Baseball, where he won the American League Cy Young Award Twice, winning the ERA Title three times and leading his league in WHIP four years in a row.
As great as Santana was, his career was relatively short for a Hall of Fame Pitcher (12 Seasons), and those who look for statistical accumulation (and many voters do), won’t find it with Santana, whose 139 Wins and 1,988 Strikeouts do not measure up to a lot of those already in Cooperstown.
Still, his career bWAR of 50.7 is excellent, and since he led the National League in that category three times, how can he not be at least considered by even those who worship traditional statistics? One thing is for sure: the results of Santana’s votes have been fascinating!