gold star for USAHOF
James Brooks and Bob Trumpy named to the Cincinnati Bengals Ring of Honor Not in Hall of Fame News

Regular visitors to notinhalloffame.com know that we are slowly working on the…

23rd Aug, 2026 Read More
The Pro Football Hall of Fame Revisited Project: 2000 Preliminary VOTE Not in Hall of Fame News

2000 PRELIMINARY RESULTS: Thank you to all who participated in the Pro…

22nd Aug, 2026 Read More
Our All Time Top 50 Buffalo Bills have been revised to reflect the 2025 Season Not in Hall of Fame News

Yes, we know that this is taking a while! As many of…

17th Aug, 2026 Read More
The Pro Football Hall of Fame Revisited Project: 1999 Final VOTE Not in Hall of Fame News

1999 Pro Football Hall of Fame Revisited Project Class. Here we are! …

15th Aug, 2026 Read More
Bergeron, Price & Tkachuk Make HHOF + The Brian Burke Committee Controversy The Buck Stops Here

Welcome back to Season 7, Episode 9 of The Buck Stops Here!…

18th Aug, 2026 Read More
Hockey Hall of Fame SHOCKERS: Brian Burke’s Self-Vote, Surprise Goalies & Tkachuk’s Call! The Buck Stops Here

The NHL season isn't truly over until the Hockey Hall of Fame…

18th Aug, 2026 Read More
How Modern Social Casino Brands Build Player Trust From the Desk of the Chairman

In the evolving landscape of free-to-play social gaming, trust stands as a…

14th Aug, 2026 Read More
Ranking the greatest NFL teams to never win a Super Bowl From the Desk of the Chairman

Football’s preseason is creeping into view, pads are popping again, and the…

12th Aug, 2026 Read More
How Dominant Pitchers Are Shaping MLB Strikeout Props Late in the Season From the Desk of the Chairman

As the MLB season enters its closing weeks, every start carries greater…

4th Aug, 2026 Read More
How Data Protection Shapes Player Confidence in Betting From the Desk of the Chairman

Online betting platforms handle more than wagers and game results. They may…

4th Aug, 2026 Read More

100 Active Potential Football Hall of Famers

Visit the Fictitious Halls of Fame!

FAHOF JPGFicRockLogo

You May Also Like...

EDITOR’S CHOICE

If I Had a Vote in the 2026 Baseball Hall of Fame Election DDT's Pop Flies

This year yielded a bumper crop of five players inducted into the…

Baseball Hall of Fame 2026: Contemporary Baseball Era Committee, Players DDT's Pop Flies

When the veterans committee (VC), officially convening as the Contemporary Baseball Era…

Project/Object Live Music Head

Project/Objectan interview with André Cholmondeleyby Live Music HeadOriginally published at timessquare.com on…

A Conversation with Greg Wyard Live Music Head

A Conversation with Greg Wyardby Live Music Head“A good song is like…

LATEST RANKINGS

550. Gojira Rock and Roll

From France, Gojira became one of the most successful and influential death…

519. M83 Rock and Roll

M83 is a French electronic project led by Anthony Gonzalez, celebrated for…

12. John Wall Basketball

In his prime, there was nobody on the court faster than John…

2. Blake Griffin Basketball

An All-American at the University of Oklahoma, Griffin was named the 2009…

Committee Chairman

Committee Chairman

Kirk Buchner, "The Committee Chairman", is the owner and operator of the site.  Kirk can be contacted at [email protected] .

The Strong National Museum of Play has announced the three new toys that will be part of the Toy Hall of Fame. 

My Little Pony, Phase 10, and Transformers beat out nine other finalists, which were Apples to Apples, Balloons, Choose Your Own Adventure Gamebooks, Hess Toy Trucks, Pokémon Trading Cards, Remote Control Vehicles, Sequence, the Stick Horse and Trampolines.

My Little Pony was first introduced by Hasbro in 1983, and boasts over a thousand varieties.

Created by Ken Johnson, Phase 10 would become the second best-selling card game, only trailing Uno.

Transformers debuted in 1984 also from Hasbro, but were promoted with a syndicated cartoon show.  There have been multiple movies and animated series since.

1969 PRELIMINARY RESULTS:

Thank you to all who participated in the Pro Football Hall of Fame Revisited Project. If you are still determining what that is, we acted like the PFHOF had its first class in January 1946.

We have completed the first 23 years thus far.

For “1969,” a Preliminary Vote with close to 100 players whose playing career ended by 1959. We are also following the structure in that players have 20 years of eligibility, and if they do not make it into the Hall, they are relegated to the Senior Pool.

Each voter was asked to select 25 names from the preliminary list, and the top 25 vote-getters were named Semi-Finalists.

A week later, the voters will be asked to pick 15 names from the 25 Semi-Finalists, and next after, they will pick five from the remaining 15. We will continue this process weekly until we catch up to the current year.

Please note that a significant change occurred “years ago,” allowing voters to submit less than the allotted spots. 

30 Votes took place.

This is for the “Modern Era”

Bold indicates they advanced to the Semi-Finals:

*Indicates they have been removed from future ballots.

Player

Year of Eligibility

Vote Total

Joe Perry FB

1

27

Bob St. Clair T

1

26

Ernie Stautner DT-DE-G

1

26

Mike McCormack T-G

2

23

Charlie Conerly QB

3

21

Leo Nomellini DT-T

1

21

Pat Harder E

11

20

Alan Ameche FB

4

20

Marshall Goldberg FB

16

19

Gene Lipscomb DT

2

19

Les Richter LB-C

2

18

Ward Cuff WB-QB-HB

17

17

Bill Osmanski FB

17

17

Vic Sears T-DT

11

17

Tank Younger FB-LB-HB

6

17

Billy Wilson E-FL

4

17

Billy Howton E-Fl

1

17

Bruno Banducci G

10

15

Woody Strode E

15

13

Harlon Hill E-DB

2

13

Les Bingaman DG-G-C

10

13

Buckets Goldenberg G-BB

19

12

Frankie Albert QB

12

11

Bucko Kilroy G-MG-T-DT

9

10

Charley Brock C-HB

17

9

Frank Cope T                               

17

8

George Wilson E

18

7

Walt Michaels LB

1

7

Spec Sanders TB

14

6

Bobby Walston E-HB-K

2

5

Kyle Rote E-HB

3

5

Duane Putnam G

2

5

Pug Manders HB-TB

17

4

Marion Campbell DE-DT-MG-G-T

3

4

Ray Renfro HB-FL

1

4

Baby Ray T

16

3

Hugh Taylor QB

10

3

Leon Hart E-FB-DE

7

3

Abe Gibron G

5

3

Pete Tinsley G

19

2

Parker Hall TB-HB

18

2

Paul Christman QB

14

2

Tommy Thompson QB

14

2

Buster Ramsey G

13

2

Ray Bray G

12

2

Paul Lipscomb T-DT

10

2

George Ratterman QB

8

2

Johnny Olszewski DB-HB

2

2

Ray Wietcha C

2

2

Bob Masterson E

18

1

Jim Lee Howell E

17

1

Chet Bulger T

14

1

Ted Frisch FB

14

1

Dick Huffman T

14

1

Bill Fischer T-G-DT

11

1

Bob Boyd E-DE

7

1

Jim David DB S

5

1

Dale Dodrill MG-LB

5

1

Chuck Drazenovich LB-FB

5

1

Hardy Brown LB-DB-FB

4

1

Woodley Lewis DB-E

4

1

Art Spinney G-DE

4

1

Tom Brookshier DB

3

1

*Dick Hoerner E 

12

0

Dub Jones B-DB-WB-TB

9

0

George Taliaferro HB-TB-QB-DB

9

0

*Bill Johnson C-LB

8

0

Warren Lahr DB

5

0

*Ray Mathews HB-E-FL

4

0

Jim Mutscheller E-DE

3

0

Will Sharman DB

3

0

*Leo Sugar DE

2

0

Harley Sewell G

1

0


This is for the “Senior Era”

Bold indicates they advanced to the Semi-Finals:

*Indicates that they will be removed from the ballot permanently.

Player

Year

Votes

George Christensen

6

16

Al Nesser

12

15

Whizzer White

3

15

Ace Gutkowski

5

12

Joey Sterneman

14

9

George Svendesen

3

9

Wildcat Wilson

15

8

Joe Kopcha

8

7

Gus Sonnenberg

14

6

Cub Buck

19

5

Gaynell Tinsley

4

5

Father Lumpkin

7

4

Jack Manders

4

4

Glenn Presnell

8

3


Please note that three voted for “None of the Above.”

We also had another vote where the voters were asked how they wanted to keep voting parameters over the next few years.  16 of 30 stated that you want to keep it as is, where YOU MUST obtain 50 percent of the vote to enter the Pro Football Hall of Fame Revisited Project.

Next week, we will announce the Semi-Finalists for the 1969 Pro Football Hall of Fame Revisited Project.

Key Takeaways

  • Controversial inductions often arise when a player's fame outweighs their stats.
  • The selection process can be muddled by unclear criteria and a lack of diversity.
  • Era differences and biases can affect who gets in and who doesn't.
  • Public perception plays a significant role in how these decisions are viewed.

Controversial NFL Hall of Fame Inductions: Are They Justified?

What makes an induction controversial? Typically, it's when a player's fame or a single memorable moment seems to overshadow their overall career performance. The Hall of Fame selection committee uses specific criteria, but sometimes personal biases and historical context can cloud these judgments.

Notable Controversial Inductions Based on Statistics and Performance

Joe Namath

Joe Namath is a classic example. His career stats—a 62-63-4 record, 50.1% completion rate, 173 touchdowns, and 220 interceptions—are not Hall of Fame material by today's standards. Yet, his bold guarantee and victory in Super Bowl III left an indelible mark on NFL history. Was it fame over skill?

Art Monk

Art Monk's induction also raises eyebrows. While his career was long and productive, his three Pro Bowl appearances seem low for a Hall of Famer. His success in three Super Bowls likely helped his case. But should longevity alone earn a spot in Canton?

Bob Hayes

Bob Hayes had blinding speed and early success but didn't sustain it. His 371 receptions and 71 touchdowns are modest compared to other Hall of Fame receivers. Did his early career brilliance and a Super Bowl win overshadow his later years?

Lynn Swann

Lynn Swann dazzled in the Super Bowl, but his career stats—336 receptions, 5,462 yards, and 51 touchdowns—don't scream Hall of Fame. His induction is a testament to the weight of Super Bowl performances. But is it fair to prioritize a few games over a whole career?

Issues with the Selection Process

Diversity in the Selection Committee

The selection committee's makeup can influence who gets inducted. More diversity, including former players and coaches, could bring varied perspectives and reduce biases. Wouldn't a broader committee better reflect the game's history?

Clear Criteria for Selection

A standardized framework for evaluating candidates could help. Clear criteria would make it easier to judge who truly deserves a spot in the Hall. Shouldn't there be a more transparent process?

Backlog of Deserving Players

Many players wait years for induction, creating a backlog. Positions like wide receiver are particularly crowded. Could clearer criteria help speed up this process?

Senior Nominees and Their Controversies

Chris Hanburger

Chris Hanburger's induction as a senior nominee came after years of being overlooked. With nine Pro Bowl appearances, his career was solid, but not outstanding. Was his senior nomination fair, or did it bypass the usual scrutiny?

Roger Wehrli

Roger Wehrli's case is similar. He wasn't seen as elite during his career, yet he made it as a senior nominee. Does his induction highlight flaws in the senior nomination process?

Coaches and Contributors: A Different Standard

Dick LeBeau

Dick LeBeau is known more for his coaching prowess than his playing days. With 62 interceptions, his playing stats are respectable but not extraordinary. Should his coaching success have been the main factor for his induction?

Marty Schottenheimer

Marty Schottenheimer's exclusion is puzzling. Despite a successful coaching career, he remains outside the Hall. Does his absence highlight inconsistencies in how coaches and contributors are evaluated?

Historical Context and Performance in Different Eras

Era Considerations

Players from different eras face varying standards. What was considered great decades ago might not hold up today. How do we fairly compare players from different times?

Super Bowl Era Bias

Some players from the Super Bowl era were overlooked initially but later inducted as seniors. Does this reflect a bias towards more recent players?

Notable Snubs and Their Impact

Steve Smith Sr.

Steve Smith Sr. boasts impressive stats and longevity, yet he remains snubbed. Is there a bias against certain positions or players from less successful teams?

Willie Anderson

Willie Anderson was a top offensive tackle but played on underperforming teams. How much should team success influence individual recognition?

Randy Gradishar

Randy Gradishar waited 35 years for induction despite a stellar career. Does his long wait reflect broader issues in the selection process?

Torry Holt

Torry Holt's continued snubbing is baffling given his strong career stats. What more does he need to prove his worthiness?

Public and Media Perception

Many Hall of Fame decisions face public and media dissent. Fans often debate the worthiness of inductees, highlighting the subjective nature of these selections. Are fans' voices being heard enough?

Subjective Nature of Selections

Opinions on player worthiness vary widely. How can the Hall of Fame balance these differing views to maintain its credibility?

Betting Lines and Hall of Fame Predictions

With the ongoing debate over who truly deserves a spot in Canton, many fans and analysts turn to metrics and predictive odds, much like those seen in FanDuel lines. These betting lines often reflect public sentiment, highlighting the players whose legacies resonate most with fans and bettors alike.

Just as in sports betting, where stats, standout moments, and subjective factors impact odds, the Hall of Fame selection process mirrors this balance of data and emotion—keeping fans invested in the ever-evolving Hall of Fame discussions.

Conclusion

Controversial inductions spark debate and keep the NFL Hall of Fame in the spotlight. They challenge us to consider what truly makes a player legendary. As the Hall evolves, will it find a way to balance fame, stats, and historical impact more effectively?

When we think about moving, the focus often falls on logistics—packing boxes, organizing, and ensuring everything makes it to the new location safely. However, some items in our homes carry far more than just physical weight; they hold memories, emotions, and connections to the past. From family heirlooms to sports memorabilia, vintage records, and treasured trophies, these are the things that define our personal history. Ensuring these items are moved with care is not just about avoiding damage but about preserving the stories and moments they represent. Here's how to move the things that hold our greatest memories with the respect they deserve.

  1. Plan Ahead and Take Inventory

The first step in moving meaningful possessions is to plan ahead. Create a detailed inventory of all the items that have sentimental value. This includes everything from framed photos, awards, sports memorabilia, and vintage collections to family keepsakes passed down through generations.

By documenting each piece, you'll not only be more organized during the move but you'll also be able to prioritize which items require the most protection. Take photographs of each item before packing to ensure you have a visual record of their condition, which can be especially helpful if you're hiring professional movers or filing insurance claims.

  1. Pack with Care

Packing items that hold your greatest memories is different from packing everyday items. Take your time with each piece, handling it gently and ensuring it's protected from every angle. If you're moving framed items, place corner protectors on each frame to avoid damage, and be sure to pack them upright to minimize pressure on the glass.

When it comes to sports memorabilia—like signed jerseys, balls, or equipment—use airtight containers to keep dust, moisture, and dirt from compromising their condition. For vintage collectibles like records, comic books, or trading cards, protective sleeves or cases are essential to preserve their value.

  1. Hire Professionals for Special Items

For particularly valuable or fragile items, hiring professional movers who specialize in handling delicate possessions is often a wise choice. Many moving companies offer specialty services for items such as musical instruments, sports equipment, and antiques. These experts know how to transport high-value items safely and securely, ensuring they arrive at your new home in the same condition as when they left.

Services like www.shiply.com are especially helpful when moving fragile or high-value items. They connect you with trusted movers who understand the specific needs of handling valuable items, from sports memorabilia to antique furniture, making sure they are transported with utmost care and precision.

In some cases, moving companies can even provide climate-controlled transportation, which is crucial for items sensitive to temperature and humidity changes, like vintage clothing, rare books, or sports memorabilia.

  1. Ensure Items Are Insured

While it's difficult to put a price on items that hold sentimental value, it's important to ensure they are protected financially during the move. Whether you're transporting a signed Hall of Fame jersey or a family heirloom that's been passed down for generations, check with your insurance provider to see if these items are covered during the move. If they're not, you may need to purchase additional moving insurance specifically for high-value possessions.

Taking this step offers peace of mind, knowing that even in the event of an accident, you have a backup plan to repair or replace items that may get damaged.

  1. Keep Sentimental Items Close

For smaller, especially meaningful items—like your first baseball glove, a trophy from a major achievement, or a keepsake from a historic sports event—you may want to keep them with you during the move. Pack these items in a separate, clearly marked box and transport them in your own vehicle rather than in the moving truck. By keeping your most cherished items close, you'll reduce the anxiety that can come with entrusting them to others.

This also applies to personal memorabilia such as family photo albums or scrapbooks. These are the items that cannot be replaced, making it essential to give them extra attention and care during the move.

  1. Unpack Mindfully

Unpacking treasured items requires the same level of care as packing them. Set aside a quiet time to unpack these special items first so you can ensure they are placed in a safe spot in your new home. As you unpack each item, inspect it to make sure it hasn't been damaged in transit.

When deciding where to place these cherished possessions in your new space, think about how they'll be displayed. Incorporating these items into your new home will help you feel more connected to the space, allowing your memories to live on and creating a new chapter for these cherished objects.

Conclusion

Moving the things that hold your greatest memories is more than just transporting objects—it's about safeguarding the moments and experiences that shaped your life. With careful planning, proper packing techniques, and a thoughtful approach, you can ensure that your most treasured items make the journey safely to your new home. These items represent your personal history, and by moving them with care, you preserve not just the physical items but the priceless memories they hold.