Tod Sloan signed with the Toronto Maple Leafs in 1946 and was called up for one game that year and 29 the year after.  The Leafs won the Cup that year, though Sloan was not on the roster.  The following season, he was there to stay.

A versatile forward who played at both Center and Right Wing, Sloan had his breakout season in 1950-51 with 31 Goals.  Sloan was on the post-season roster for Toronto that year, and he got his name engraved on the Stanley Cup that year.  Sloan remained strong the year after, leading the NHL in Power Play Goals in 1951-52, but he would struggle in the two seasons after, failing to come close to 20 Goals.

Sloan rebounded in 1955-56, with 37 Goals and a league-leading 28 on Even Strength.  He was named a Second Team All-Star and was the runner-up to Montreal's Jean Beliveau for the Hart.  He played two more years in Toronto before he was traded to Chicago.

As a Leaf, Sloan had 346 Points.

Bobby Baun reminds us a lot of Paul Henderson in that he is best known for one game.  Baun fractured his ankle early in Game 3 of the 1964 Stanley Cup Championship but returned to the ice to score the game-winning goal against the Detroit Red Wings and would help Toronto win the Cup that year.

Overall, Bob Baun had an excellent stay-at-home blueline career in the National Hockey League, where he was a five-time All-Star, four-time Stanley Cup winner, and was the NHL leader in Defensive Point Shares (1960-61).  He is also a five-time All-Star.

Dick Duff began his career with the Maple Leafs in 1954, where he showed his gritty two-way play quickly as an asset.

Duff would be one of the players around whom Toronto was rebuilt.  While he was not a scoring machine, he was a glue guy who was capable of digging his skates in where necessary and doing the grinding necessary to win games.  The Left Wing had three straight seasons (1956-57 to 1958-59) where he had at least 26 Goals, and he would play a large part in Toronto’s 1962 and 1963 Stanley Cup wins.

Duff was traded late in the 1963-64 Season to New York in a deal that sent over Andy Bathgate.  Duff missed out on the Maple Leafs’ Stanley Cup that year, but he won four more with Montreal.  As a Leaf, Duff scored 342 Points.

Duff entered the Hockey Hall of Fame in 2006.

Ken Randall was an original member of the Toronto Arenas when the National Hockey League formed, and we will make the case that he was one of the most underrated players of the era.

Randall played mostly on the blueline but would occasionally play at Right Wing when needed.  A Stanley Cup champion immediately when the Arenas won it all, he was also a champion in 1922, when the then-named St. Pats won it again.  Except for his first year, Randall was in the top ten in Defensive Point Shares each season he was in Toronto, which ended when he was traded to Hamilton.

With Toronto, Randall had a good run with 86 Points in 128 Games.