A+ A A-

10. John Coltrane

Rate this item
(2 votes)

With this selection, we approach an artist who we just couldn’t figure out where to place; or even if we should place him at all. Was John Coltrane right for the Roots and Early Influence category? We didn’t think so as his greatest success and period of influence was simultaneous with the British Invasion. Does Jazz have a viable place in the Hall? We think so, as Miles Davis is in and many a Rock genre is Jazz infused. Besides, if any Jazz great had a “Rock Star” quality, it was John Coltrane.

Coltrane first came to prominence as a sideman with Miles Davis, and would later lead his own Jazz group in 1960 which released several acclaimed albums. He simultaneously became one of the genre’s most important and controversial stars. Coltrane’s work always pushed the envelope veering into Free Jazz and Avant-Garde Jazz. His music was not always understood but as the years passed the appreciation of his music grew. We aren’t sure if another Jazz great will make the Rock and Roll Hall, but we are sure that if one does we believe it should be John Coltrane.

 
John Coltrane

The Bullet Points:

 

Eligible Since:

1981

Country of Origin:

U.S.A. (North Carolina)


Why He Will Get In:

He has unquestionable status as a musical legend.

Why He Won’t Get In:

With the exception of Miles Davis, no Jazz figure has entered the Hall.


Nominated In:

Never


Essential Albums:

My Favorite Things (1961)

A Love Supreme (1964)

Living Space (1965)

Interstellar Space (1967)


Our Five Favorite Songs as Chosen by Each Member of the NIHOF Committee:

My Favorite Things (From My Favorite Things, 1961)

Brazilia (From The John Coltrane Quartet Plays, 1964)

A Love Supreme Part 1: Acknowledgement (From A Love Supreme, 1965)

A Love Supreme Part 3: Pursuance (From A Love Supreme, 1965)

Untitled Original 90320 (From Living Space, 1965)


www.johncoltrane.com


 

 

 

 

Should John Coltrane be in the Hall of Fame?

(You must be registered and logged in to vote!)
Definitely put him in! - 50%
Maybe, but others deserve it first. - 4.5%
Probably not, but it wouldn't be the end of the world. - 27.3%
No opinion. - 0%
No way! - 18.2%
Last modified on Saturday, 01 February 2014 12:34

Comments   

 
0 #1 Darryl Tahirali -0001-11-29 19:00
John Coltrane is probably the greatest tenor saxophonist in jazz history. He has influenced countless jazz musicians and continues to do so even nearly a half-century after his death. Coltrane has exerted little if any influence on rock music, and he evinced no tangible interest in the form during his life. There is no earthly reason why he should be in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.The write-up on this web page makes no sense whatsoever, or else it indicates a fundamental ignorance or misunderstandin g of jazz. As I explained in my lengthy justification of why Miles Davis deserved his induction into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, Davis actively and deliberately incorporated rock rhythms into his post-bop jazz on two landmark albums in 1969, In a Silent Way and Bitches Brew. It was an unprecedented and controversial move that earned Davis heavy criticism from the jazz world, although many of the jazz musicians on either or both of those albums went on to form jazz-rock "fusion&qu ot; bands in the 1970s, thus reinforcing the influence rock had on jazz
Quote
 
 
0 #2 Knuckles -0001-11-29 19:00
There isn't a single musical artist I would rather listen to than John Coltrane. But Trane's candidacy lies in how influential he was and just how much importance is placed on influence. Most of the truly influential non-Rock performers are in, and nothing in Rock was a direct result of how Coltrane was playing.
Quote
 
 
0 #3 Darryl Tahirali -0001-11-29 19:00
Maybe in another 20 years rock will be where 'Trane was 50 years ago today. Always great to meet another fan!
Quote
 
 
-2 #4 Sean -0001-11-29 19:00
No, not an influence on rock. Great artist though.
Quote
 
 
+3 #5 smoore -0001-11-29 19:00
Duane Allman, Robby Krieger, Calos Santana, Phil Lesh and John McLaughlin would all disagree with you about Coltrane's influence on rock music and rock musicians. By the way, I do to.
Quote
 
 
0 #6 biograph 2013-05-12 04:23
Yes, Coltrane should be in. And as we expand our definition of "rock," let's bring in Fela Kuti along with long overdue inductions for Frank Sinatra, Bing Crosby, Peggy Lee and Nat "King" Cole. The Hall wants to celebrate POPULAR music, of which rock is just a subset, so it's name notwithstanding , the Hall should celebrate more icons of popular music. (Are Frank and Nat already in under that "influences" category, I wonder?)
Quote
 

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

Login

Click an icon to login instantly with your social account. (If you are logged into Facebook, clicking the Facebook icon will log you in to Not in Hall of Fame instantly.)

Search

  • 61. The New York Dolls
    A common thread on this list is musicians who are ahead of their time. We can’t help but think there may be no other band on this list that defines that opening sentence better than the New York Dolls, who not only helped define a sound but a look as well.   The New York Dolls became the blueprint for…
Add new comment
  • red gold blue

    © 2009-2012 Kirk Buchner & David Johnson