A member of the 100 Sack club, Robert Mathis proved time and time over his career that he was a certified beast on the pass rush. 

Percy Harvin was a two time BCS Champion at the University of Florida where he was considered the team’s offensive spark.  The Minnesota Vikings would draft Harvin in the First Round, where his rookie year was his best year in the NFL earning Pro Bowl honors and was consider a bona fide dual threat as a receiver and returner.  He never had a season that good again, but still had a respectable 353 Receptions with three seasons in the top ten in All-Purpose Yards.

Generally fans don’t wear the jersey of Punters but Pat McAfee of the Indianapolis Colt was such a character that he bucked the trend and actually made a few residuals off his last name on fans backs. 

Justin Forcett bounced around the National Football League, playing for seven different teams in eight different seasons.  Now granted this does not reflect a player who could not have been that good, but remember seven different NFL teams thought enough of the skill of the Running Back for him to play regular season games for them.