214. Michelle McCool

The WWE career of Michelle McCool did not exactly start with a bang as she was a distant runner-up in the Diva Search and her first angles resulted in largely forgettable programs. However subtlety her in-ring work and natural athleticism came to light and she would become the first ever WWE Diva’s Champion. McCool’s best work would be late in her career as a heel in a pair with fellow diva, Layla, but if she ever gets in, it would be as a result of that work.

Should Michelle McCool be in the Hall of Fame?

Definitely put her in! - 85.9%

Maybe, but others deserve it first. - 3.8%

Probably not, but it wouldn't be the end of the world. - 3.8%

No opinion. - 1.3%

No way! - 5.1%

The Bullet Points

Billed From: U.S.A. (Palatka, California)
Key Championships Held: WWE Women’s (2)
WWE Divas (2)
Why they will get in: They like to induct women every year and being the wife of the Undertaker doesn’t hurt.
Why they won't get in: Her run as a top female was not very long.
Five Greatest Matches/Moments: 1. Defeated Natalya to win the first ever Diva’s Championship at the Great American Bash (7/20/08)
2. Defeated Melina Perez for the WWE Women’s Title (6/28/09)
3. Successfully defended her title defeating Mickie James at the TLC PPV (12/13/09)
4. Regained the Women’s Title defeating Mickie James (2/26/10)
5. Unified the Women’s and Divas Title by defeating Melina Perez at Night of Champions (9/19/10)