gold star for USAHOF
The Pro Football Hall of Fame Revisited Project: 1998 Final VOTE Not in Hall of Fame News

1998 Pro Football Hall of Fame Revisited Project Class. Here we are! …

24th Jul, 2026 Read More
The Tennessee Titans announce Chris Johnson to their Ring of Honor Not in Hall of Fame News

Regular visitors of notinhalloffame.com know that we are slowly working on the…

23rd Jul, 2026 Read More
Virginia Tech names its 2026 Hall of Fame Class Not in Hall of Fame News

Regular visitors of notinhalloffame.com know that we are slowly working on the…

22nd Jul, 2026 Read More
The Pro Football Hall of Fame Revisited Project: 1998 Semi-Final VOTE Not in Hall of Fame News

1998 SEMI-FINAL RESULTS: Thank you for your participation in the Pro Football…

18th Jul, 2026 Read More
Our All Time Toronto Blue Jays have been revised to reflect the 2025 Season Not in Hall of Fame News

Yes, we know that this is taking a while! As many of…

17th Jul, 2026 Read More
Our All Time Top 50 Texas Rangers have been revised to reflect the 2025 season Not in Hall of Fame News

Yes, we know that this is taking a while! As many of…

14th Jul, 2026 Read More
Why Blackjack Remains the Most Iconic Casino Table Game From the Desk of the Chairman

Blackjack has remained one of the most recognizable casino table games for…

22nd Jul, 2026 Read More
Hockey Hall of Fame Predictions: Bergeron, Marleau, Zetterberg & The Don Cherry Debate! The Buck Stops Here

Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian break down their predictions for the upcoming…

20th Jul, 2026 Read More
Are the Chicago Bears Moving to Indiana? | Jack Silverstein Breaks Down the Stadium Drama The Buck Stops Here

Are the Chicago Bears really leaving Illinois for Hammond, Indiana? In this…

20th Jul, 2026 Read More
Is Omar Vizquel a Hall of Famer? | 90s Indians, Ozzie Smith & NHL Talk The Buck Stops Here

Welcome back to a special episode of The Buck Stops Here! Host…

20th Jul, 2026 Read More
From Childhood Hobby to High-Value Asset: The Business of Sports Card Collecting with Bill Murphy The Buck Stops Here

Host Kirk Buchner sits down with New England-based sports card expert Bill…

19th Jul, 2026 Read More
The Untold Story of Nolan Ryan: Secrets, Speed & The Man Behind the Legend | Tim Brown Interview The Buck Stops Here

In this special episode of The Buck Stops Here, host Kirk Buchner…

19th Jul, 2026 Read More

100 Active Potential Football Hall of Famers

Visit the Fictitious Halls of Fame!

FAHOF JPGFicRockLogo

You May Also Like...

EDITOR’S CHOICE

If I Had a Vote in the 2026 Baseball Hall of Fame Election DDT's Pop Flies

This year yielded a bumper crop of five players inducted into the…

Baseball Hall of Fame 2026: Contemporary Baseball Era Committee, Players DDT's Pop Flies

When the veterans committee (VC), officially convening as the Contemporary Baseball Era…

Project/Object Live Music Head

Project/Objectan interview with André Cholmondeleyby Live Music HeadOriginally published at timessquare.com on…

A Conversation with Greg Wyard Live Music Head

A Conversation with Greg Wyardby Live Music Head“A good song is like…

LATEST RANKINGS

550. Gojira Rock and Roll

From France, Gojira became one of the most successful and influential death…

519. M83 Rock and Roll

M83 is a French electronic project led by Anthony Gonzalez, celebrated for…

12. John Wall Basketball

In his prime, there was nobody on the court faster than John…

2. Blake Griffin Basketball

An All-American at the University of Oklahoma, Griffin was named the 2009…

21. Big Star

This page generously sponsored by: Nobody yet! Sponsor it on Patreon to be the first name on this list!

The NIHOF Committee knew that we had would be placing many artists that achieved limited commercial success. Yet when we looked at Big Star, we just couldn’t figure out why they never did hit the mainstream. Had they achieved more than just critical acclaim, they would likely be in the Hall already.

One has to wonder if Big Star was just plain unlucky. Drawing from the melodies and harmonies from the British Invasion groups along with an American Rock edge they became the embodiment of Power Pop. Considering their influences and that their music appeared radio friendly, it is strange that they never did catch on with the public and essentially remained anonymous. Although their time as a band was brief and their record sales were dismal the 80’s saw a new batch of guitar based alternative bands (R.E.M. & The Replacements for example) that emerged citing Big Star’s work as a big influence on the music they were creating. Considered, now a cult band, the biggest question around Big Star was not why they didn’t produce more music: but why the music they put out was barely played in the first place. Had it been, they may have lived up to their moniker.

Big Star 

 

 

www.bigstarband.com

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Should Big Star be in the Hall of Fame?

Definitely put them in! - 66.4%
Maybe, but others deserve it first. - 11%
Probably not, but it wouldn't be the end of the world. - 6.2%
No opinion. - 0%
No way! - 16.4%

The Bullet Points

  • Previous Rank: 2010: #19
    2012: #19
    2013: #19
    2014: #16
    2015: #17
    2016: #17
  • Eligible Since: Thursday, 01 January 1998
  • Country of Origin: U.S.A. (Memphis, TN)
  • Why they will get in: They meet the influence criteria which include current Hall members, R.E.M.
  • Why they won't get in: Cult bands generally don’t have a shot.
  • Nominated in: Never
  • Essential Albums: #1 Record (1972)
    Radio City (1974)
    Third/Sister Lovers (1978)
  • Our Five Favorite Songs as Chosen by Each Member of the NIHOF Committee: Thirteen (From #1 Record, 1972)
    In the Street (From #1 Record, 1972)
    September Gurls (From Radio City, 1974)
    What’s Going Ahn? (From Radio City, 1974)
    Kanga Roo (From Third/Sister Lovers, 1978)

Should Big Star be in the Hall of Fame?

Definitely put them in! - 66.4%
Maybe, but others deserve it first. - 11%
Probably not, but it wouldn't be the end of the world. - 6.2%
No opinion. - 0%
No way! - 16.4%
Last modified on Monday, 20 April 2026 16:35

Comments powered by CComment