If the Football Hall of Fame were based solely on excitement, there should be no doubt that Randall Cunningham would have been inducted on the first ballot. His nickname, the “Human Highlight Reel,” was well deserved, and he was hands down the most entertaining Quarterback of his era.
Randall Cunningham could beat you with his throwing arm or with his legs. He excelled at scrambling and is the current all-time leader for rushing yards (4,928) for a Quarterback. This made him exciting to watch but also overshadowed his passing. Cunningham was an efficient thrower, and as his speed began to wane, he was able to prove to a lot of people in the league that he could throw with the best of them.
Cunningham's scrambling was not always effective, as he was sacked a lot. He did, however, bring so many weapons (he was also a great punter) to the field that he inspired a new generation of mobile, multi-faceted quarterbacks. Cunningham never won the AP MVP, but he was a three-time Bert Bell Award winner, and also won a PFWA MVP and NEA MVP. Doesn't that show how incredible he was? This should be enough to warrant a look from the Hall, though it hasn’t happened yet, and may never
Regardless of whether Cunningham makes the PFHOF, he is one of the most influential Quarterbacks in Football, and that can never be taken away from him.
It may be called the Pro Football Hall of Fame, but for all intents and purposes, it only focuses on accomplishments from the NFL and, to a lesser extent, the AFL. This is too bad for Herschel Walker, who chalked up monster totals in his first three years of Pro Football but did so as a member of the New Jersey Generals of the upstart United States Football League.
Walker went to the Dallas Cowboys and tried to live up to the PlayStation-like numbers he put up in College and in the USFL. Walker was still very good and put up good numbers for Dallas in both receiving and running the ball. He was, however, the focal point of one of the more lopsided trades in NFL history, where the Vikings sent five players and a multitude of draft picks (three of which were Emmitt Smith, Alvin Harper, and Darren Woodson). Dallas used this to build a dynasty in the ’90s, and Minnesota coaches took their frustration out on Walker, who wasn’t used to his best ability as a Viking. Herschel was still good, but his stock dropped dramatically.
That lopsided trade hurt his legacy, but Herschel Walker should be remembered as a great Running Back who contributed in pass and kick return situations. If he were a rookie today coming out of Georgia, where there is no USFL, would he have had a shot to shatter NFL rushing records?
Sadly, we will never know.
Chuck Foreman was called the “Spin Doctor”, but it was not due to his ability to spin his words. It was because he could effortlessly spin his body around would-be tacklers, making it look like ballet.
When people think of the Minnesota Vikings of the 1970s, they recall the Purple People Eaters and Fran Tarkenton's scrambling. They should also remember the offensive exploits of Chuck Foreman, who twice led the National Football League in Touchdowns. He may have been a Running Back, but he was often used for his receiving skills and was the league leader in that category in 1975. Watching Foreman run with the ball was like watching a rhinoceros. While he could spin away from defenders, he often tried to overpower them, though that style also led to multiple fumbles (52 in 109 Games)
The career numbers of Chuck Foreman may not seem like a lot now (9,106 YFS/76 TD), but they were quite good for the era he played in. He did make the Minnesota Vikings Ring of Honor, but reaching the NFL version of that accolade may continue to prove difficult.