gold star for USAHOF
 
Committee Chairman

Committee Chairman

Kirk Buchner, "The Committee Chairman", is the owner and operator of the site.  Kirk can be contacted at [email protected] .

Xander Bogaerts didn't just emerge from Aruba; he became the island’s greatest baseball ambassador. Signed in 2009, he ascended rapidly through the system, reaching Boston in 2013 just in time to provide high-leverage hits during the Red Sox's improbable World Series run. By 2014, he was the everyday shortstop, embarking on a decade-long stretch where he combined a smooth right-handed stroke with a steady defensive presence that anchored the Fenway infield.

A four-time All-Star and five-time Silver Slugger in Boston, Bogaerts proved to be one of the most consistent offensive threats at his position. His 2019 campaign stands as his statistical masterpiece: he launched a career-high 33 home runs, drove in 117 runs, and posted an OPS of .939. This performance earned him a fifth-place finish in the MVP voting and an All-MLB First Team selection, a hardware proxy that confirms his status as the premier shortstop in the game during that window.

His run in Boston was rooted in his durability and leadership. Bogaerts was a key cog in the record-breaking 2018 championship team, providing the veteran stability and postseason production (including a .273 average in the World Series) that defined that era. Even as the roster around him shifted, Bogaerts remained one of the faces of the franchise, batting .307 in his final season in Boston (2022) and leading all AL shortstops in fielding percentage.

The "Bogie" era in Boston came to a shocking conclusion following the 2022 season when he departed for the San Diego Padres as a free agent. It was a move that felt unthinkable to a fan base that viewed him as the next lifetime Red Sox icon. He left Fenway with 1,410 hits, 156 home runs, and a stellar .292 career average in a Red Sox uniform. Though he later plied his trade on the West Coast, his two World Series rings and his decade of excellence ensure his place in the Red Sox Hall of Fame is already a certainty.

Austin Meadows was part of the trade that sent Chris Archer to the Pirates at the 2018 Trade Deadline, and the young Outfielder is showing the skills to be the top player of the transaction.

Meadows became an All-Star in 2019 on the strength of a 32 Home Run/.291/.346/.558 year where he was 14thin MVP voting. Meadows helped Tampa reach the World Series the following year, and in 2021, Meadows was a large part of the team that went back to the playoffs, as he had 27 Home Runs and 106 RBIs, although he had a less-than-desirable Batting Average (.235), and On Base Percentage (.315).  Tampa dealt Meadows to the Tigers during 2020 Spring Training, ending his run in the state of Florida.

With the Rays, Meadows had 308 Hits with 65 Home Runs.

9. Brandon Lowe

Brandon Lowe is still early into his career but he has been very impressive thus far.

Playing at Second Base, Lowe debuted in 2018, but still qualified as a rookie in 2019, where he was third in Rookie of the Year voting, batted .336, and was an All-Star.  It was especially impressive considering that Lowe missed nearly half the season due to shin and quad issues.  In the COVID-shortened 2020 season, Lowe was an All-MLB Team 2 Selection, showing that he is poised for greatness in a full season.  That is what he gave Tampa in 2021, with a tenth-place finish in MVP voting where he belted 39 Home Runs with 99 RBIs.  

Lowe is still with Tampa though over the last three seasons, he has missed significant time over the last three seasons.  He enters 2025 with 126 Home Runs with a career .812 OPS.

22. Joey Wendle

Joey Wendle led the West Chester Golden Rams to a Division II Championship in 2012, and he followed it up with a pro career, first with the Oakland Athletics, where he played minimally before he was traded to Tampa.

Wendle won the Second Base job out of Spring Training in 2018, and the versatile defensive player was fourth in American League Rookie of the Year voting while batting an even .300.  Wendle was hurt through much of 2019, but was a top player on the 2020 team that won the Pennant.  In 2021, Wendle had another good year with Tampa, going to the All-Star Game, with an 11 HR/.265 year.  

After the 2021 Season, Tampa traded Wendle across the state to Miami.  With the Rays, the infielder had 371 Hits.