Not in Hall of Fame News
At 6:00 AM this morning (why do they always do it this…
25th Feb, 2026
Read More
Not in Hall of Fame News
A.J. Styles has been named to the WWE Hall of Fame. Last…
24th Feb, 2026
Read More
Not in Hall of Fame News
Yes, we know that this is taking a while! As many of…
24th Feb, 2026
Read More
Not in Hall of Fame News
1991 SEMI-FINAL RESULTS: Thank you for your participation in the Pro Football…
21st Feb, 2026
Read More
Not in Hall of Fame News
Yes, we know that this is taking a while! As many of…
17th Feb, 2026
Read More
Not in Hall of Fame News
1991 PRELIMINARY RESULTS: Thank you to all who participated in the Pro…
14th Feb, 2026
Read More
The Buck Stops Here
In this candid and insightful episode of The Buck Stops Here, Kirk…
24th Feb, 2026
Read More
From the Desk of the Chairman
Have you ever asked yourself why some football teams play like they…
24th Feb, 2026
Read More
From the Desk of the Chairman
Here's what LA's president of baseball operations, Andrew Friedman, didn't need to…
24th Feb, 2026
Read More
From the Desk of the Chairman
Three superstars, three sports; one question for all the fantasy managers who…
23rd Feb, 2026
Read More
The Buck Stops Here
In this heartfelt episode of The Buck Stops Here, host Kirk Buchner…
23rd Feb, 2026
Read More
The Buck Stops Here
In this emotionally charged episode of The Buck Stops Here Hall of…
21st Feb, 2026
Read More
100 Active Potential Football Hall of Famers
-
#96 Overall, Derwin James, Los Angeles Chargers, Strong Safety, #6 Safety2024 Pre-Season Rank #130, 2023: Pre-Season Rank #136. Peak Period: 2018-24* After a spectacular rookie year (2018) where he was the runner-up for the…in Safeties -
#86 Overall, Jedeveon Clowney, Free Agent, Defensive End, #19 Defensive Linemann/Linebackers: Pass Rushers2024 Pre-Season Rank #92,2023 Pre-Season Rank #89, 2022 Pre-Season Rank #87, 2021 Pre-Season Rank #89, 2020 Pre-Season Rank #85. Peak Period: 2015-19.More of a… -
#39 Overall, Roquan Smith, Baltimore Ravens Linebacker, #4 Defensive Lineman/Linebacker: Interior Lineman2024 Pre-Season Rank #62, 2023 Pre-Season Rank #92, 2022 Pre-Season Rank #133, 2021 Pre-Season Rank #146. Peak Period: 2020-24 Smith was a Second-Team… -
#100 Overall, Chris Lindstrom, Atlanta Falcons, Right Guard, #15 Offensive Lineman2024 2023 Pre-Season Rank #149. Peak Period: 2020-24 Chris Lindstrom has slowly turned into one of the best Guards in football and is…
Visit the Fictitious Halls of Fame!
You May Also Like...
EDITOR’S CHOICE
DDT's Pop Flies
When the veterans committee (VC), officially convening as the Contemporary Baseball Era…
Live Music Head
Project/Objectan interview with André Cholmondeleyby Live Music HeadOriginally published at timessquare.com on…
LATEST RANKINGS
MOST POPULAR RANKINGS
Committee Chairman
Kirk Buchner, "The Committee Chairman", is the owner and operator of the site. Kirk can be contacted at [email protected] .
Fictitious Athlete Hall of Fame is coming
Oct 08, 2013
Published in
Not in Hall of Fame News
We here at Notinhalloffame.com are very excited to announce that we are a few weeks away from unveiling a brand new section that we feel will combine our love of Sports and Pop Culture perfectly. Our goal here at our website, has always been to shed a bit of insight on some of the omissions in the most important Halls of Fame in North America, and as the only website that combines a look at post career institutions of Rock of Roll, Baseball, Football, Hockey, Basketball, NASCAR and the WWE. Receiving this tribute is considered to be a stamp of approval, and proof that you were among the elite at what you accomplished.
Thus far, we feel we have only scratched the surface. There has been some healthy debate, but of course we always want to see more of the same. Now, it is one thing to talk about existing Halls of Fame; it is quite another to create one of your own. Ladies and Gentleman, brace yourselves for the next section on our website; The Fictitious Athlete Hall of Fame.
What is the Fictitious Athlete Hall of Fame (or as we will start calling it, the FAHOF)? It is a Hall where we will celebrate and induct the greatest sports characters in Television and Movies. This will be a perpetual process, where annually all of you will vote on these characters and decide which ones deserve to be in this Hall of Fame. With the exception of our inaugural inductee (and we are confident that this will not be a selection that will create controversy) this is a vote controlled only by the people who visit our site to vote; and who better than the people to determine this?
The FAHOF (get used to this acronym) will not just be for athletes. We have been inspired by the other Halls of Fame we cover here, as we have created also a “Contributors” section, for those who were not performers in the sport but assisted in sports film and television in different ways.
We look forward to this launch, which will come very soon!
Football Senior Candidates
Oct 01, 2013
Published in
Not in Hall of Fame News
We have not mentioned it here at Notinhalloffame.com but the Football Hall of Fame Seniors’ Committee nominated two men who hold a strong ranking on our Football rank.
Punter, Ray Guy and Defensive End, Claude Humphrey have been selected as the two Senior Nominees. Unlike the last few years, both Guy and Humphrey shined brightest in the 1970’s, whereas past Senior’s nominees were from either the 50’s and/or 60’s.
This isn’t the first time that Humphrey has appeared as a nominee. In 2009, he was on the ballot with Bob Hayes, who was selected. Humphrey was a dominating force for the Atlanta Falcons, and twice was a First Team All-Pro and a Second Team selection three times. He was an impact player immediately, capturing the Defensive Rookie of the Year honors in 1968 and would finish with 122 credited Quarterback Sacks. Only Dick Stanfel has been nominated by the Senior Committee twice without securing a spot in Canton. The odds of Claude Humphrey being the second aren’t strong.
Out of the 51 men (and we are counting men who have been selected twice) who have been named as a Senior nominee, 38 have been admitted as a Football Hall of Fame nominee. Those are pretty good odds, wouldn’t you say? Humphrey may be the man on the ballot for the second time, but that is not where the attention is focused. That is going towards Punter, Ray Guy.
Kickers and Punters are the second tier of Professional Football. They aren’t the same size, they don’t get the glory when they help their team win but take the brunt when their squad loses. Amazingly, with all of that against the Punter, there has been a push to induct Ray Guy, who revolutionized the position during his tenure with the Raiders.
Blog after blog has proclaimed that Ray Guy’ omission from the Hall of Fame is a travesty, despite how much the sport looks down upon special teams; an opinion that exists among many fans. With all of this said, this is the exception to the rule. With the exception of Guy, there has been no push from any Football media to select any other Punter for the Hall of Fame, and there probably never will be again. It is not like Guy has not been heavily considered before, as he was a Hall of Fame finalist seven times (1992, 1995, 1997, 1999, 2002, 2007 & 2008). In terms of accolades, he certainly fits the Canton bill.
Ray Guy was the first (and to date, only) Punter ever selected in the first round of the NFL Draft. Guy was chosen by the Oakland Raiders, and though fans initially did not see the value in drafting a pure special teams player that high in the draft, it was proven that this was a man who was going to revolutionize the position.
It was alleged that because of Ray Guy, that the National Football League started to keep track of Hang Time; returning teams found his punts near impossible to return. 210 of his career punts were within his opponents’ 20 Yard Line. His skills indirectly led the Raiders to the first line of defence in games. Guy was named to the 1970’s All-Decade Team, Six Pro Bowls, Three First Team All-Pro Teams and the 75th Anniversary Team.
Even more importantly, the legacy of Ray Guy is growing. Often time diminishes performance, but Guy has become a strange anomaly; a man who defies rules despite the red headed stepchild syndrome of special teams stereotypes. Despite being only a “Punter”, the popular conception is that he belongs in the Hall of Fame; even if no other kicker ever follows him in.
Something tells us that the special teams bias is going to buckle in 2014.
RIP: L.C. Greenwood
Oct 01, 2013
Published in
Not in Hall of Fame News
The Steel Curtain lost one today. Former Pittsburgh Steelers, Defensive End, L.C. Greenwood passed away due to kidney failure at the age of 67.
The popular defender was part of four Super Bowl wins and was named to the 1970’s All-Decade Team. Continued accolades include six Pro Bowl Selections and two First Team All-Pro teams. Greenwood is currently not in the Football Hall of Fame, though he was a Finalist twice. He is ranked #8 on our Notinhalloffame.com Football List, and is considered an omission by Canton not just by us, but by many football fans and writers.
We offer our condolences to the family and friends of L.C. Greenwood.
Mariano Rivera: Cooperstown Bound
Sep 28, 2013
Published in
Not in Hall of Fame News
The yearlong farewell tour of Mariano Rivera has concluded and the consensus is that this is the end of the greatest Reliever in Baseball history. Virtually every statistic shows this, from the traditional to the obscure, and a handful of World Series rings cement it. Theory would dictate that the best player of a sporting position would be a Hall of Fame lock, though there is a distinct example where this isn’t the case.
Edgar Martinez spent the majority of his career as the Designated Hitter for the Seattle Mariners and is acknowledged as the top DH ever. The Baseball Hall of Fame voters have not responded with an affirmative to induction. Four decades after the Designate Hitter was instituted in the American League, there is a still hatred of the position, and not just by Baseball purists. The belief that is a part time role isn’t exactly wrong, though it is when applied to that of the Relief Pitcher.
Pitchers have become a specialized art. Bullpens are larger than they were thirty years ago, and the idea of a hurler receiving a standing ovation for allowing two runs and six hits over five and a third innings would have been laughable in the previous generation. The reality is that Relief Pitching is not going anywhere, and in regards to Cooperstown, there is evidence to support it. Lee Smith retired as the active saves leader and his Hall of Fame support has not changed much since he became eligible. There have been many blogs over the past month that have challenged what should be Rivera’s inevitable induction, and those that have, have challenged the spots of closers in the Hall.
The Reliever is not the Designated Hitter, in that they have broken through to Upstate New York. Hoyt Wilhelm, Rollie Fingers, Bruce Sutter, Dennis Eckersley and Goose Gossage have all been enshrined. Rivera may have been more of a specialist than the five just mentioned, but he unarguable has done that better than anybody.
Rivera will retire as the all-time Saves leader. The Save is in itself a controversial statistic, as far too often it is awarded in situations that hardly merit a whole number. Like the Win, it is not an accurate measure of a Pitcher’s ability but, again, like the Win, a huge number cannot be ignored. A career number of over 650 Saves stands out, though that is not necessarily the statistic that impresses us the most.
Prior to his retirement, the Panamanian had the lowest active Earned Run Average and 13th overall in the career number (minimum 1,000 Innings Pitched). Every Pitcher with a lower ERA came from an era where there career ended decades before Rivera was born. Mariano’s career WHIP of 1.000 gives him a third place all-time rank which again has no equal among his peers. Ten times, Rivera posted a sub 1.000 WHIP and is the career leader in ERA+. He never won the Cy Young, but was voted in the top five on five occasions. He is number three all-time in WPA (Win Probability Added) and fourth in Strikeouts to Walks Ratio; and he did it all with one pitch, a cut Fastball that everybody knows is coming and can’t seem to do anything about.
What the naysayers of Rivera fail to point out is his unparalleled post season accomplishments. This is not about accumulation, like Andy Pettitte, another Yankee who is retiring. Pettitte’s post season stats match his regular season accomplishments, but Rivera took his dominance to an even greater level when the lights were brighter
Over his 141 Innings Pitched in October, his Earned Run Average dropped to 0.70, a full run and a half under what his spectacular regular season average was. His WHIP decreased from 1.000 to 0.759 and he posted 42 Saves. This isn’t just dominance, this is almost mythological! Let’s also remember in the post-season you are only competing against the elite!
Mariano Rivera is not just a Hall of Fame Pitcher but should be a first ballot inductee. We thank Rivera for his nineteen years of class and service in Major League Baseball and wonder when we will see his like again.