Anthony Costanzo was the player who the Indianapolis Colts used their First Round Pick on in the 2011 Draft (22^ndOverall), and the Lineman from Boston College would play his entire pro career (10 seasons) wearing the horseshoe on his helmet.

Costanzo started all 144 of his Games Played at Left Tackle, where he had three years where he exceeded double-digits in Approximate Value.  While he was never a Pro Bowler, he was on the cusp of a few, and he was highly regarded in the Hoosier State.

Alex Smith came into the pros with lofty expectations, and how could that not be the case when you are a Quarterback who was taken first overall?  From Utah, it was the San Francisco 49ers who chose him in 2005, but it was a mixed bag of success, as he struggled on the field and with injuries. 

Missing the 2008 season due to shoulder issues, Smith had to fight to get his job back in 2009, but again, he could not make the upper-echelon of NFL Quarterbacks, though he took the Niners to the playoffs in 2011, and looked to have turned a corner.  Smith got off to his best start in 2012, but a concussion led to him replaced in a game by Colin Kaepernick, who eventually became the permanent starter.  With Kaepernick’s ascendence, Smith was traded to the Kansas City Chiefs after the season’s conclusion.

Smith’s tenure at Arrowhead was the best of his career.  A chief for five seasons (2013-17), Smith led Kansas City to four post-seasons, and he went to three Pro Bowls.  His best year was 2017, where he led the NFL in Passer Rating (104.7) and had career-highs in Passing Yards (4,042) and Passing Touchdowns (26), but this would be his last year with the Chiefs, as they had a young QB in Patrick Mahomes in wait.  Smith, who helped mentor Mahomes, was dealt to Washington, but tragedy was on the horizon.

On November, 18, 2018, Smith broke his right leg when he was tackled by Houston’s Kareem Jackson and J.J. Watt.  Following his first surgery, Smith contracted flesh-eating disease, and it got so bad that amputation was considered.  Seventeen surgeries later, he began rehab, and was a back-up in 2020, until an injury to Kyle Allen put Smith back into the game.  Smith played six Games in 2020, winning five, and he was rewarded with the Comeback Player of the Year Award.

Smith retired with 35,650 Yards, a nice amount for a player that always seemed to be a placeholder.  

Zach Brown played eight years in the NFL, but while he is best known for his first four seasons with Tennessee and two strong years with Washington, his lone year in Buffalo (2016) would be his Pro Bowl season.

The Linebacker had 17.5 career Sacks and 664 Tackles.

Undrafted from South Carolina in 2011, Patrick DiMarco made an NFL roster the year after with the Kansas City Chiefs.  DiMarco was only in KC for a year and was used as a Fullback for three years with the Atlanta Falcons, where he was a Pro Bowler in 2015.  He finished his career with three years in Buffalo.