gold star for USAHOF
The Pro Football Hall of Fame Revisited Project: 2002 Semi-Final VOTE Not in Hall of Fame News

2002 SEMI-FINAL RESULTS: Thank you for your participation in the Pro Football…

10th Oct, 2026 Read More
Our All Time Top 50 Detroit Lions have been revised to reflect the 2026 Season Not in Hall of Fame News

Yes, we know that this is taking a while! As many of…

8th Oct, 2026 Read More
Our Notinhalloffame Football list has been updated: 281-300, Part 15 Not in Hall of Fame News

We are diligently working away at Notinhalloffame on revising our Football lists…

5th Oct, 2026 Read More
Our Notinhalloffame Football list has been updated: 241-260, Part 13 Not in Hall of Fame News

We are diligently working away at Notinhalloffame on revising our Football lists…

4th Oct, 2026 Read More
Maximizing Your Gameday Bankroll: A Sports Fan’s Guide to Top Online Gaming Bonuses From the Desk of the Chairman

Sports fans thrive on calculating strategy, reading momentum, and maximizing every tactical…

3rd Oct, 2026 Read More
Best NFL Prediction Market Apps and Platforms From the Desk of the Chairman

The 2026 NFL season is two weeks old and the division races…

30th Sep, 2026 Read More
From Casual Games to Organized Competition: Why Pickleball Is Becoming a Team Sport Favorite From the Desk of the Chairman

Sports communities are often built around things that have nothing to do…

28th Sep, 2026 Read More
What Separates a Great Induction Ceremony From a Long Night From the Desk of the Chairman

Every hall of fame eventually faces the same problem. The selection process…

25th Sep, 2026 Read More
Why Second Looks Matter: Reconsidering The Betting Bans In A Sport That Sells Betting From the Desk of the Chairman

Pete Rose died in 2024. On May 13, 2025, Commissioner Rob Manfred…

24th Sep, 2026 Read More
How to Create the Perfect Football Game Day From the Desk of the Chairman

For NFL fans, game day offers much more than three hours of…

18th Sep, 2026 Read More

100 Active Potential Football Hall of Famers

Visit the Fictitious Halls of Fame!

FAHOF JPGFicRockLogo

You May Also Like...

EDITOR’S CHOICE

If I Had a Vote in the 2026 Baseball Hall of Fame Election DDT's Pop Flies

This year yielded a bumper crop of five players inducted into the…

Baseball Hall of Fame 2026: Contemporary Baseball Era Committee, Players DDT's Pop Flies

When the veterans committee (VC), officially convening as the Contemporary Baseball Era…

Project/Object Live Music Head

Project/Objectan interview with André Cholmondeleyby Live Music HeadOriginally published at timessquare.com on…

A Conversation with Greg Wyard Live Music Head

A Conversation with Greg Wyardby Live Music Head“A good song is like…

LATEST RANKINGS

550. Gojira Rock and Roll

From France, Gojira became one of the most successful and influential death…

519. M83 Rock and Roll

M83 is a French electronic project led by Anthony Gonzalez, celebrated for…

12. John Wall Basketball

In his prime, there was nobody on the court faster than John…

2. Blake Griffin Basketball

An All-American at the University of Oklahoma, Griffin was named the 2009…

Committee Chairman

Committee Chairman

Kirk Buchner, "The Committee Chairman", is the owner and operator of the site.  Kirk can be contacted at [email protected] .

Regular visitors of Notinhalloffame.com know that we are slowly working on the top 50 of every major team in the NHL, NBA, NFL and MLB.  Once that is done, we intend to look at how each team honor their past players, coaches and executives.  As such, it is important to us that the

The University of Iowa has already announced its intention to retire the #22 of Caitlin Clark.

This is an incredible achievement for Clark, whose career just concluded, and it places her in rarified air.  Few organizations and institutions seldom make an announcement like this after a player leaves, and it can’t be argued that Clark deserves to be in this group.

Clark, who will presumably be the first overall pick by the Indiana Fever this draft, set the NCAA record for Points (3,951) and carried the Hawkeyes on her back to two straight Finals.

We here at Notinhalloffame.com would like to congratulate Caitlin Clark for this impending honor.

1959 PRELIMINARY RESULTS:

Thank you to all of you who have participated in the Pro Football Hall of Fame Revisited Project. If you are unaware of what that is, we acted as if the PFHOF had its first class in January 1946.

We have completed the first 14 years thus far.

For “1958,” a Preliminary Vote with close to 130 players whose playing career ended by 1952. We are also following the structure in that players have 20 years of eligibility, and if they do not make it into the Hall, they are relegated to the Senior Pool.

Each voter was asked to select 25 names from the preliminary list, and the top 25 vote-getters were named Semi-Finalists.

A week later, the voters will be asked to pick 15 names from the 25 Semi-Finalists, and next after, they will pick five from the remaining 15. We will continue this process weekly until we catch up to the current year.

Please note that a significant change occurred “years ago”, allowing voters to submit less than the allotted spots. 

31 Votes took place

This is for the “Modern Era”

Bold indicates they advanced to the Semi-Finals:

*Indicates they have been removed from future ballots

Player

Year of Eligibility

Vote Total

Bill Dudley HB-TB-QB

1

27

Bill Willis G

1

26

Max Speedie E

2

26

Ace Gutkowski FB-TB

15

25

Arnie Weinmeister DT

1

25

Ward Cuff WB-QB-HB

7

23

Bill Osmanski FB

7

23

Whizzer White TB-HB

12

22

Wayne Millner E-DE

9

22

Marshall Goldberg FB

6

22

Ken Kavanaugh E

4

22

George Christensen T-G

16

21

Buckets Goldenberg G-BB

9

21

George Svendsen C

13

18

George Wilson E

8

18

Lou Rymkus T

3

17

Woody Strode E

5

16

Frankie Albert QB

2

16

Glenn Presnell T-B

18

15

Charley Brock C-HB

7

15

Frank Cope T                               

7

15

Spec Sanders TB

4

14

Pat Harder E

1

14

Gaynell Tinsley E

14

12

Vic Sears T-DT

1

8

Buster Ramsey G

3

6

Al Blozis T

10

5

Jack Manders

14

4

Russ Letlow G-T

8

4

Pug Manders HB-TB

7

4

Tommy Thompson QB

4

3

Jack McBride FB

20

3

Nate Barragar C-G

19

3

Joe Kopcha G

18

3

Bill Owen T-G

18

3

Stumpy Thomason WB-TB-BB-HB

18

3

Father Lumpkin BB

17

3

Baby Ray T

6

3

Doug Wycoff B

20

2

Bo Molenda FB-HB-BB

19

2

Luke Johnsos E

18

2

Swede Hanson B

16

2

Milt Gantenbein E

14

2

Eggs Manske E

14

2

Bernie Masterson QB

14

2

Bull Karcis FB-BB-HB

12

2

Parker Hall TB-HB

8

2

Roy Zimmerman QB-WB

6

2

Paul Christman QB

4

2

Otto Schellenbacher S

3

2

Ray Bray G

2

2

Bill Fischer T-G-DT

1

2

Tom Nash E

20

1

Keith Molesworth HB-QB

17

1

Potsy Jones G

16

1

Ozzie Simmons HB

15

1

Tony Blazine T

13

1

Pete Tinsley G

9

1

Merl Condit HB

8

1

Gary Fangietti FB-HB

8

1

Frank Filchok TB-QB-HB

8

1

Bob Masterson E

8

1

Jim Poole E

8

1

Ed Rucinski E

8

1

Ki Aldrich C-LB-G

7

1

Jim Lee Howell E

7

1

Ed Kolman T

7

1

Bill Radoivch G

7

1

Billy Dewell E

5

1

Glenn Dobbs TB-QB

5

1

Chet Bulger T

4

1

Ted Frisch FB

4

1

Dick Huffman T

4

1

Elmer Angsman HB

2

1

Tex Coulter T-E-C

2

1

Dick Hoerner E

2

1

Ray Poole R

2

1

Johnny Strzykalski HB

2

1

Jerry Shipkey LB-FB-DB

1

1

*Zuck Carlson G-T-C-LB

18

0

*Carl Brumbaugh B

16

0

*Lou Gordon T-G-E

16

0

*Ookie Miller C-G-LB

16

0

*Joe Zeller G-E

16

0

*Ralph Kerchaval WB

14

0

Jim Barber T

13

0

Ed Danowski B

13

0

Johnny Drake B

13

0

*Clyde Shugart G

10

0

Conway Baker G-T

9

0

Joe Carter E

9

0

Andy Farkas FB-HB-WB

9

0

Gene Ronzani T

9

0

*Bill Lee T

8

0

*Orville Tuttle G

8

0

*Willie Wilkin T

8

0

Dick Plasman E-T

7

0

Elbie Schultz T-G

7

0

Joe Aguire E

5

0

Larry Craig B-E

5

0

Dick Humbert E-DE

5

0

John Woudenberg T

5

0

*Jack Ferrante E

4

0

*Dante Magnami HB-WR

4

0

*Bob Nowasky E

4

0

*Steve Pritko E

4

0

*Bob Reinhard T-FB

4

0

*Norm Standlee FB-LB

4

0

Fred Davis T-DT

3

0

Vic Lindskog C

3

0

Ed Neal MG-C-G-T

3

0

*Visco Grgich G

2

0

*Jim Keane E

2

0

Dick Wildung G-DT-T

1

0

This is for the “Senior Era”

Bold indicates they advanced to the Semi-Finals:

*Indicates that they will be removed from the ballot permanently.

Tony Latone

4

20

Al Nesser

3

18

Hunk Anderson

9

17

Wildcat Wilson

5

14

Cub Buck

9

8

Joey Sternaman

4

7

Gus Sonnenberg

4

6

Gull Falcon

14

5

Sol Butler

14

4

Two-Bits Honan

4

4

Herman Kerchoff

14

4

Henry McDonald

14

4

Steamer Horning

14

3

Bob Shiring

14

3

Pete Stinchcomb

7

3

Doc Alexander

7

3

Duke Osborne

6

2

*Jug Earp

2

1

*Ray Kemp

1

1

*Joe Lillard

1

1

*Hap Moran

1

1

*Harry Robb

11

0

*Curly Oden

2

0

*Milt Rehnquist

2

0

*Jack Spellman

2

0

*Rudy Comstrock

1

0

*Chuck Kassell

1

0

*Dick Stahlman

1

0

In the special vote, modern candidates are removed if they have no votes on years 2,4,6,8,10,12,14,16,18.

We will post the 1958 Finalists of the Pro Football Hall of Fame Revisited Project results next Saturday.

Thank you to all who contributed. If you want to be part of this project, please let us know!

124. Jon Lester

In the year 2000, the two most cursed franchises in baseball were the Chicago Cubs and Boston Red Sox. Given their history of bad luck, many believed it would be another hundred years before either of these big market teams won a championship. While Jon Lester did not break these curses (he wasn't in the Majors when Boston broke it in 2004), he played a significant role in two squads that had been struggling for decades.

Lester was a second-round pick by the BoSox in 2002 and joined the main roster in 2006. While he played well, he had enlarged lymph nodes that required off-season treatment. Fortunately, Lester recovered and returned to the Red Sox the following summer, where he gained a win in the 2007 World Series, his first championship. After that, Lester became a high-end starter.

In 2008 and 2009, Lester won a combined 31 games with 377 strikeouts. He went to his first All-Star game in 2010, led the AL in SO/9 (9.7), and was fourth in Cy Young voting. He struck out 225 batters, with a 3.25 ERA and a career-high 19 wins. He was an All-Star again in 2011 (15-9, 3.47 ERA) but slipped in 2012 (9-14, 4.82 ERA), which was cause for concern in Fenway.

However, in 2013, Lester rebounded and went 15-8. His postseason was phenomenal as he went 4-1, including two wins in the World Series with a 0.59 ERA. He went to the All-Star game again in 2014, but the struggling Red Sox traded him to the surging Athletics for their playoff run. Although Oakland did not get past the first round, Lester's overall season was his best in years, as he finished fourth in Cy Young voting with an overall performance of 16-11, 220 strikeouts, and a 2.46 ERA.

Lester became a free agent and signed with the Chicago Cubs. He had his ups and downs with the Cubs, but his up years were memorable. He won 19 games in 2016 with a 2.44 ERA and was again an All-Star. Most importantly, Lester led Chicago to their first World Series win in over a century, and he won the NLCS MVP and was named the Babe Ruth Award winner. He was an All-Star again in 2018 (his fifth), but he struggled afterward and retired after brief runs in Washington and St. Louis.

Lester retired with three World Series rings, an even 200 wins, and 2,488 strikeouts.

Jon Jay

Jon Jay had a 12-year career as an outfielder, but he was not known for his power-hitting. He hit only 37 home runs throughout his career. However, he did have seven seasons in which he had over 100 hits and batted over .290 five times. Jay's willingness to help his team is also reflected in his ranking in the top 100 all-time in Hit by Pitch. He spent most of his career with St. Louis, where he played for six seasons and won a World Series in 2011. He also played for San Diego, Chicago (NL), Kansas City, Arizona, Chicago (AL), and Los Angeles (AL). Jay had a lifetime batting average of .283 with 1,087 hits.