gold star for USAHOF
The Baltimore Orioles name their 2026 Hall of Fame Class Not in Hall of Fame News

Regular visitors of Notinhalloffame.com know that we are slowly working on the…

2nd Apr, 2026 Read More
The Notinhalloffame Baseball list has been revised: 51-75 Not in Hall of Fame News

Last January, the Baseball Hall of Fame announced the Class of 2026,…

2nd Apr, 2026 Read More
The Hulk Hogan vs Andre the Giant Wrestlemania III match named to the WWE Hall of Fame Not in Hall of Fame News

The WWE Hall of Fame announced that the Hulk Hogan vs Andre…

31st Mar, 2026 Read More
Bad News Brown named to the WWE Hall of Fame Not in Hall of Fame News

It was announced that Bad News Brown will be inducted into the…

31st Mar, 2026 Read More
The Pro Football Hall of Fame Revisited Project: 1993 Preliminary VOTE Not in Hall of Fame News

1993 PRELIMINARY RESULTS: Thank you to all who participated in the Pro…

28th Mar, 2026 Read More
The Hidden Risks of Overtraining: Why Sports Make You Stronger… Until They Don’t From the Desk of the Chairman

Sports and regular physical activity are widely celebrated for building strength, improving…

2nd Apr, 2026 Read More
2025 United States Athletics Hall of Fame Inductees Revealed! | Full Announcement Show The Buck Stops Here

The wait is over! Join the NotInHallOfFame.com crew—Kirk Buchner, Evan Nolan, and…

2nd Apr, 2026 Read More
Who Gets In? Debating All 8 Candidates on the HOF Contemporary Era Ballot | Roundtable Discussion The Buck Stops Here

Join Kirk Buchner and Evan Nolan from NotInHallOfFame.com for a special roundtable…

2nd Apr, 2026 Read More
MLB's PED Era Stars NOT in the Mitchell Report The Buck Stops Here

Kirk Buchner (NotInHallOfFame.com) and Robert Dobek dive into the dark shadow the…

2nd Apr, 2026 Read More
The Buck Stops Here - Hall of Fame News - S6E15 PFHOF Surprise Debuts | Federer's HOF Slam Dunk The Buck Stops Here

Kirk Buchner and Evan Nolan return for Season 6, Episode 15 of…

1st Apr, 2026 Read More
Pro Football Hall of Fame Class of 2026: Full Semifinalist Breakdown The Buck Stops Here

Kirk Buchner and Paul Lawrence sit down to break down the newly…

1st Apr, 2026 Read More
2025 United States Athletics Hall of Fame Inductees Revealed! | Full Announcement Show The Buck Stops Here

The wait is over! Join the NotInHallOfFame.com crew—Kirk Buchner, Evan…

MLB's PED Era Stars NOT in the Mitchell Report The Buck Stops Here

Kirk Buchner (NotInHallOfFame.com) and Robert Dobek dive into the dark…

S1E29 - Pro Football Hall of Fame Debates, NFL Parity, and the Dumb Ass of the Week Not In: All In

Kirk Buchner, Longhorn Dave Whitlock, and Chris Mouradian dive into…

100 Active Potential Football Hall of Famers

Visit the Fictitious Halls of Fame!

FAHOF JPGFicRockLogo

You May Also Like...

EDITOR’S CHOICE

If I Had a Vote in the 2026 Baseball Hall of Fame Election DDT's Pop Flies

This year yielded a bumper crop of five players inducted into the…

Baseball Hall of Fame 2026: Contemporary Baseball Era Committee, Players DDT's Pop Flies

When the veterans committee (VC), officially convening as the Contemporary Baseball Era…

Project/Object Live Music Head

Project/Objectan interview with André Cholmondeleyby Live Music HeadOriginally published at timessquare.com on…

A Conversation with Greg Wyard Live Music Head

A Conversation with Greg Wyardby Live Music Head“A good song is like…

LATEST RANKINGS

561. Gojira Rock and Roll

From France, Gojira became one of the most successful and influential death…

530. M83 Rock and Roll

M83 is a French electronic project led by Anthony Gonzalez, celebrated for…

12. John Wall Basketball

In his prime, there was nobody on the court faster than John…

2. Blake Griffin Basketball

An All-American at the University of Oklahoma, Griffin was named the 2009…

Site Admin

Site Admin

24. Tony Mullane

How many people pointed at Bert Blyleven’s 287 career wins year after year and championed his Hall of Fame cause?  We don’t know the exact number, but we are sure that it is a lot more than those who created logs extolling the virtues of Tony Mullane’s 284 Major League victories.

Maybe people should marvel at those wins.  Mullane was an ambidextrous hurler who could easily baffle batters, as back in his day, pitchers did not wear gloves, thus they had no idea which arm he would throw with.  Mullane was an innings-eater who recorded 30 wins on multiple occasions.  Like many in his day, Mullane was a very much a free spirit who challenged the reserve clause, was suspended for the 1885 season, and sat out part of the 1892 season in protest over pay cuts.  This may have cost him the magical 300-win number, and the fact that he played in the American Association (and not the National League) and had subpar seasons late in his career has made the switch-pitching Tony Mullane a distant afterthought among the folks at Cooperstown.

Should Tony Mullane be in the Hall of Fame?

Definitely put him in! - 69.6%
Maybe, but others deserve it first. - 19.6%
Probably not, but it wouldn't be the end of the world. - 5.4%
No opinion. - 1.1%
No way! - 4.3%

77. Willie Randolph

It is strange to say that Willie Randolph played in a bit of a shadow as he was a long-time Yankee, but that is somewhat true.  He was in the shadow of other more flamboyant New York stars, and his strong defensive play never got him a Gold Glove as he played at the same time as Lou Whitaker or Frank White.  Hell, even his current Coaching career seems to overshadow his accomplishments on the diamond.  It shouldn’t, though, as Willie Randolph was a very good ballplayer.

Willie Randolph may have been a multi-time AAll-Star but it was many of the little things that got him there.  He showed incredible patience at the plate and drew many free passes to help set the table for his squad’s power hitters.  He was an excellent fielder and a clubhouse leader.  He may not have been an offensive juggernaut, but he was a consistent performer and often the most reliable.

Randolph did not receive an abundant amount of support for the Hall of Fame, but the Bronx faithful remember him as one of the better players in their history.  Considering the New York Yankees' history, this is indeed high praise.

Should Willie Randolph be in the Hall of Fame?

Definitely put him in! - 52.9%
Maybe, but others deserve it first. - 16.8%
Probably not, but it wouldn't be the end of the world. - 21%
No opinion. - 0%
No way! - 9.2%

41. Will Clark

Will Clark is a justifiable member of the Mississippi Sports and College Baseball Hall of Fame, but it looks like the big one in Cooperstown will elude him as he failed to get past his first year of eligibility.  A look at his career makes you wonder why he couldn’t get past that elusive first ballot.

Nicknamed “The Thrill”, Will Clark became an instant favorite as he homered on his first at-bat against the legendary Nolan Ryan.  Clark would become a major star in the Bay Area, exciting fans with his unequaled competitiveness and solid offensive play.  He was ranked among his peers as the top clutch performer in the game, as evidenced by his 1989 NLCS MVP.  The six-Time All-Star finished his career with a Batting Average over .300 and solid power numbers.  What hurt Will Clark was that the inflated power numbers that came after him (especially from other first basemen) made what he accomplished look less special.  It is very possible that “The Thrill” could pop up in a Veterans’ Committee discussion in the future.

Should Will Clark be in the Hall of Fame?

Definitely put him in! - 71.8%
Maybe, but others deserve it first. - 17.9%
Probably not, but it wouldn't be the end of the world. - 4.7%
No opinion. - 0%
No way! - 5.6%

66. George Van Haltren

One of the main staples of this website is to discuss the overlooked.  We certainly are not the only ones to do this, as other websites and blogs discuss those they feel are Hall of Fame-worthy, but no matter how you slice it, it is hard to find anyone with more HOF credentials who has been completely abandoned than George Van Haltren.

A star of the last decade of the 1800’s, Van Haltren was a hitting machine who slapped away at singles like they were mosquitoes.  He was constantly in the top ten in multiple Batting categories, and he was a huge asset with his glove, as he led the league three times in outfield assists.  In addition, he could be called upon to pitch when needed and actually finished his career with a respectable won-loss record of 40- 31.  With over 2,500 career hits and 1,600 career runs, how is it possible that he is not even on the radar?

Should George Van Haltren be in the Hall of Fame?

Definitely put him in! - 77.8%
Maybe, but others deserve it first. - 16%
Probably not, but it wouldn't be the end of the world. - 1.2%
No opinion. - 0%
No way! - 4.9%