Not in Hall of Fame If it's not in the Hall of Fame, it's at Not in Hall of Fame

2023 Fictitious Contributor Round 1

Oscar Arguella

Contest: 2023 Fictitious Contributor Round 1
TV Show/Movie Appeared: Pitch (2016)
Actor/Actress: Mark Consuelos
Why you should vote:: Generally GMs are ruthless in fictional team sports. This guy has a soul.
Why you should not vote:: The Padres never won a World Series…and dating your mentor’s daughter? Not cool!
Oscar Arguella was not much of a baseball player, and the talent he did have was wasted. He was given another chance by his then Manager, Al Luongo, to become a Scout and through hard work and introspection he worked his way up to General Managers position of the San Diego Padres, a team in which Luongo still Manages. (How long has he Luongo been with San Diego?)

If his backstory gets better and if the show lasts, this could be a sleeper for the Hall.