Not in Hall of Fame If it's not in the Hall of Fame, it's at Not in Hall of Fame

2023 Fictitious Athlete Hall of Fame - Round 1

Charlie Tweeder

TV Show/Movie Appeared: Varsity Blues (1999)
Actor/Actress: Scott Caan
Position Portrayed: Wide Receiver
Played For:: West Canaan HS
Why you should vote:: It is one of the cooler names in the pantheon of movie athletes.
Why you should not vote:: Like we said, Caan may have had a good physique, but he lacked the athletic believability of his father.
We did not really have a problem with the performance of Scott Caan as Charlie Tweeder, the main Wide Receiver for West Caanan, but we were not exactly sure what it was supposed to be. Was he the ladies’ man, the comedian, or the future prison inmate? It was a little disjointed, but our biggest issue is not buying Scott Caan as an athlete, but wasn’t he a little short to be a Wide Receiver in a solid Texas High School Football program? This was the same guy who stood eye to eye to the diminutive “E” in Entourage.