First off, glad to see the fringe list off the table right now. At best it should only have been used for pioneers like Frank Gotch, Ed "Strangler" Lewis, Rikidozan, or backstage technical people like Jim Johnston or Kevin Dunn. People WWE do not have footage of or just support staff who can't easily be ranked with the talent or promoters.
The celebrity list with William Shatner replacing Mike Tyson is good. He has hosted RAW, did a storyline angle with Lawler in the mid 90s and inducted Lawler into the Hall of Fame. If he just appears at a pay-per view, he could solidify his spot. However I still have reservations about Dennis Rodman. Again, he was a WCW celebrity who no-showed a lot of events and rubbed people the wrong way. I don't think WWE is in any hurry to induct him nor needs to. His spot would be better served with Tom "Tiny" Lister or Leslie Nielsen.
The Future list.... it's sort of all over the place. Marcus Bagwell? Bobby Lashley? Not sure how they are future Hall of Famers. Maybe Bagwell could get ranked in the top 250...in the back. Sting should be ranked in the top 250 as he's going into the TNA Hall of Fame and WWE tried to induct him into their Hall of Fame in 2011.
The future list should be guys like John Cena, Randy Orton, Brock Lesnar, CM Punk, Daniel Bryan, Sheamus, Stephanie McMahon, Vickie Guerrero, Michael Cole, Santino Marella, The Great Khali, The Miz, and other current superstars who have pretty much earned their place or are on the clear path to the Hall. Batista too, though he's off doing movies. Guys like X-Pac, Teddy Long, Great Muta, Chavo Jr, D Lo Brown and so on can get ranked however high or low they should be. Guys like Rey Mysterio, Big Show, Kane, are probably worth ranking given they made it big long before the likes of Cena or Orton, but if not they too can stay on the futures list. Guys like Christian, Mark Henry, and the Hardy Boys could be added too.
Perhaps the biggest move from the future list should be Vince McMahon. Frankly, I think he should be ranked number 1 on the top 250, followed by Sammartino and Savage.
The Top 250. Toots Mondt, Jack Tunney, Gory Guerrero, Edouard Carpentier, Angelo Savoldi, Linda McMahon, Sky Low Low, Leroy McGuirk, Hans Schmidt, and Danny Hodge should be added. Joey Styles, Lance Russell, Harvey Whippleman, George Crybaby Cannon, Bulldog Brower, Gene LeBell, Paul Boesch, The Crocketts, Bruce Prichard and Willie Gilzenberg are also worthy.
Scott Irwin, Eric Embry, Bunkhouse Buck, Chris Kanyon, Marc Mero, Jose Estrada Sr, Iceman King Parsons, Tojo Yamamoto, Giant Haystacks, Tor Kamata, Hard Boiled Haggerty, Mark Rollerball Rocco, Gino Hernandez, Jay Youngblood, Buzz Sawyer, Chris Adams, Brad Armstrong, Jacqueline, Otto Wanz, and Kendo Nagasaki can probably be replaced. Haystacks I'd consider more of a fringe person anyways since he's foreign, dead, and never worked for WWE. Same could be said about Shinya Hashimoto or Mitsuharu Misawa. In fact, there are a lot of Japanese guys on the list who probably will never make it. But I figured I'd mention Toshiaki Kawada and Aja Kong as potential replacements too. Kong at least is still alive and worked briefly for WWE.
Still think guys like Slick, Lord Alfred Hayes, and the New Age Outlaws should be in the top 100 while guys like Jody Hamilton, Shane Douglas, and Ole Anderson should be bumped back.
Those are my current thoughts. What's everyone else thinking?