Mike Ribiero had a long career in the National Hockey League, the center of which was with the Dallas Stars.  It was also the best part of his career.

There was nothing flashy about Curt Giles' game, but NHL teams need players who are defensive stalwarts, a role he played very well. 

Is this rank too high or too low?

If you think it is too high, it may be because you are pointing out that Brett Hull was only with the Dallas Stars for three seasons, a relatively short period compared to many on this list.  While he was an All-Star once in Dallas and was still certainly productive, he was not putting up the exact explosive numbers he did in St. Louis, where he led the NHL in Goals, three of which were 70-plus.  His highest goal-scoring season in Dallas was 32.