For many, Jackie Gleason could do no wrong, and like so many great comedians, he could tap into a dark place to generate dramatic performances that make you forget how funny he could be. Here, Gleason is Maish Rennick, the degenerate boxing manager of “Mountain” Rivera, who lost a sizable sum of money wagering when his client lost to a young Cassius Clay. That wasn’t the entire part of the story as we would later learn, but his moral compass is clearly skewed, but as a character you can’t help but be compelled by what is on the screen in front of you.
The Bullet Points: Movie Appeared: Requiem for a Heavyweight (1962)
Actor: Jackie Gleason
Role Portrayed: Boxing Manager
Why You Should Vote For Him: Gleason was great here, but wasn’t he always?
Why You Should Not Vote For Him: For the amount of contenders available for the Veteran’s Category, perhaps just being a manager here is not enough to get selected.
Based on Rod Serling’s 1956 teleplay, the version of Requiem of a Heavyweight that we have decided to go with is the Anthony Quinn 1962 film. Quinn, plays Luis “Mountain” Rivera, who like so many of our Veteran’s Candidate boxing films, finds us looking at a boxer at the end of his career.
He may be at the end of his career, but what a way to start to the film! We see him at the receiving end of punches from Cassius Clay (playing himself) and learn that his weasel of a manager bet significant money on his client to defeat Clay (or so we thought) causing him to be in debt to the mob, and having Rivera denigrate himself to become “Big Chief Mountain Rivera” in the Professional Wrestling racket to bail him out. Watching Quinn punch may be painful to watch (I guess that explains the opening shot where we only see Clay punch) as he does not look like a boxer, but since we well before the days if true method acting, we give Zorba a pass.
The Bullet Points: Movie Appeared: Requiem for a Heavyweight (1962)
Actor: Anthony Quinn
Role Portrayed: Boxer/Wrestler
Why You Should Vote For Him: Quinn was great and at his apex (in our opinion as an actor).
Why You Should Not Vote For Him: With all due respect to Zorba, his punches didn’t look like they could break paper.
Ah, American cockiness meets British snobbery. A Yank at Oxford is a simple fish out of water story, but it works, and here it is set on the backdrop of rowing at Oxford; which is as is steeped in tradition as Hockey is in Canada or Sumo Wrestling in Japan. The cocky American here is Lee Sheridan (Robert Taylor) and as you would expect there is a woman involved, (an eventual) successful attempt to master a new sport and respect earned at the end. Hey, there is nothing wrong with formula, especially (like here) when it is done right. Oh, and by the way it is far superior to when Rob Lowe tried it fifty years later!
The Bullet Points: Movie Appeared: A Yank at Oxford (1938)
Actor: Robert Taylor
Role Portrayed: A rower at Oxford
Why You Should Vote For Him: Rowing is an underrated sport, and there is no better nominee from this sport.
Why You Should Not Vote For Him: Underrated, overrated or properly rated. Most people don’t care.
Sometimes we forget what a great comedic duo Dean Martin and Jerry Lewis was. From their 1951 film, “That’s My Boy”, Lewis plays Junior Jackson, the son of two distinguished athletes, but remember this is Jerry Lewis, so what kind of athlete do you expect him to be? Bill Baker (Dean Martin) helps Jackson make the Ridgefield College Football Team (Jackson’ father alma mater) and through events that could only be done by Jerry Lewis somehow wins the big game. We bet this was huge in France!
The Bullet Points: Movie Appeared: That’s My Boy (1951)
Actor: Jerry Lewis
Role Portrayed: College Football Player for Ridgefield College
Why You Should Vote For Him: Well, he won the big game at the end and earned the respect of his father.
Why You Should Not Vote For Him: As a football player, this guy was horrendous!