Sonja Henie was a three time Olympic Gold Medalist in Ladies Figure Skating, and arguably the Norwegian was the most known female athlete in the world. How do you parlay that success? Well in Hollywood of course! Henie would embark on a successful second career, which began in “One in a Million”, where she played…a figure skater that competes at the Olympics. Good thing they already had the footage.
The Bullet Points: Movie Appeared: One in a Million (1936)
Actor: Sonja Henie
Role Portrayed: Olympic Figure Skater.
Why You Should Vote For Her: This may baffle today’s generation, but this lady was a major and bankable star.
Why You Should Not Vote For Her: This was no stretch in terms of a performance for Henie, and this was a generic story at best.
We never cared who Richard Harris played, as we loved him in almost everything he did (except for when he sang MacArthur Park). In 1963, he was cast as Frank Machin, a coal miner consumed with anger, which was perfectly transferred to the rugby field where he became a local star. However, this was not a case where channeled rage into sports was therapeutic, as Machin showcased far deeper issues, and Rugby was more of a backdrop to what was really going on inside.
Ironically, though this featured Rugby, which is big in the U.K., and not in the United States, did better and was more critically received on the west side of the pond.
The Bullet Points: Movie Appeared: This Sporting Life (1963)
Actor: Richard Harris
Role Portrayed: Loose Forward for a local Rugby team in Yorkshire
Why You Should Vote For Him: We don’t have a higher profile Rugby nominee.
Why You Should Not Vote For Him: As good as Machin was as a Rugby player, the film was more about his issues with anger as opposed to athleticism.
We may not have been all that interested in the sub-plot love triangle with Joanne Woodward and Robert Wagner, but Paul Newman, an avid race fan himself was brilliant as Frank Capua, an automobile racer who is competing at the Indianapolis 500. There are very few American actors who could tell such a compelling story with just his eyes, and with riveting race scenes, cameos by legitimate drivers, we have what we think could be a solid candidate for the Veterans Category for the Fictitious Athlete Hall of Fame.
The Bullet Points: Movie Appeared: Winning (1969)
Actor: Paul Newman
Role Portrayed: Auto Racer
Why You Should Vote For Him: Newman gave us multiple performances in the regular athlete category that are worth a look. He might have been even better here.
Why You Should Not Vote For Him: It never seems to matter how many racing pictures there are; somehow it never feels like a sports film.
Comedian, Joe E. Brown gives us a great morality tale about a cocky young Chicago Cubs star that needs to be taught a lesson in humility off the field so that he could become a team player on it. This is the most known of Brown’s three Baseball flicks, so we thought it best to use this one as the nominee. You can tell us if it is in fact the best one.
The Bullet Points: Movie Appeared: Elmer, the Great (1933)
Actor: Joe E. Brown
Role Portrayed: Chicago Cubs star
Why You Should Vote For Him: Baseball was magical in those days, and a way we learned lessons. Why not this?
Why You Should Not Vote For Him: When you think of 1930’s Hollywood stars, you don’t think of Joe E. Brown.