Before arriving in Canada in mid-2009, Edwin Encarnación was mostly seen as a mysterious, unpolished third baseman—a player with remarkable raw power but who often struggled with consistency at the plate and in the field. When the Toronto Blue Jays brought him over from Cincinnati at the trading deadline as part of the deal for Scott Rolen, it seemed like a small risk for a fresh start. With time, patience, and a few twists within the organization, that initial gamble paid off, transforming him into one of the most powerful and intimidating middle-of-the-order hitters in franchise history.
His initial years in Ontario were challenging. Following an inconsistent 2010 campaign, the front office subjected him to waivers, resulting in his claim by Oakland. However, when the Athletics non-tendered him a few weeks later, the Toronto Blue Jays seized the opportunity to re-sign him on a low-risk contract. This decision proved to be a strategic display of patience. While Encarnación continued to contend with defensive limitations in the corner positions, the Toronto staff implemented a permanent structural adjustment by predominantly deploying him as a designated hitter by mid-2011. Freed from defensive concerns, his right-handed batting performance experienced a complete transformation.
That positional shift paved the way for an exceptional breakthrough masterpiece in 2012. Dominating American League pitching throughout the summer, Encarnación established himself as an elite performer by hitting 42 home runs and driving in 110 runs. He combined this formidable power with a sophisticated approach, achieving career-highs across his entire .280/.384/557 slash line and ultimately finishing 11th in the AL MVP voting.
Encarnación, far from being merely a one-season wonder, established himself as the preeminent designated hitter of the mid-2010s. He was renowned for celebrating his home runs with his distinctive "Edwing" arm gesture as he rounded the bases. Throughout an impressive five-year peak, he consistently secured a position in the cleanup spot, surpassing the 30-home run mark each summer and recording a minimum of 98 runs batted in during all those seasons. His continued excellence was exemplified by a remarkable 2016 campaign, during which he led the major leagues with a career-high 127 RBIs. Although he narrowly missed receiving the Edgar Martinez Award amid an era populated with elite designated hitters, traditional voters regularly acknowledged his influence by awarding him MVP votes in four of those five peak seasons.
Most importantly, his heavy-handed run production served as the emotional and statistical engine that lifted the franchise out of its long postseason drought. He anchored back-to-back playoff teams in 2015 and 2016, famously cementing his place in Toronto lore by launching a legendary walk-off three-run home run in the 11th inning of the 2016 AL Wild Card Game against Baltimore, a swing that shook the foundations of Rogers Center.
Following that thrilling postseason run, Encarnación entered the open market as a free agent and eventually signed a lucrative multi-year contract with Cleveland ahead of the 2017 season.
With the Blue Jays, Encarnacion compiled 977 hits, 239 home runs, and 679 RBIs while generating an outstanding .268/.355/.522 slash line (134 OPS+).
Comments powered by CComment