Not in Hall of Fame

As the eldest of the Smith family of Hockey players from Ottawa, Alf Smith had a bit of a rough road to the Hall of Fame. Smith started his career in the 1890’s but was declared ineligible for amateur contests and did not play in what was likely his prime. He would however reclaim his eligibility and had his most famed years as the Player/Coach of the Ottawa Silver Seven where he averaged two goals a game and led his team to three consecutive Stanley Cups.

Should Alf Smith be in the Hall of Fame?

I totally agree with this induction. - 60%

I am fine with this induction. - 0%

I do not agree with this induction, but it does not bother me. - 0%

No opinion. - 0%

Kick him out! - 40%

The Bullet Points

Country of Origin: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
Elected In: Monday, 01 January 1962
Position: Right Wing
Played For: Ottawa Senators
Non-NHL Teams: Ottawa Hockey Club
Pittsburgh PAC
Ottawa Silver Seven
Kenora Thistles
Pittsburgh Duquesne
Pittsburgh Bankers
Major Accolades and Awards: Stanley Cup Rings (3) (Ottawa Silver Seven 1904, 1905 & 1906)

Should Alf Smith be in the Hall of Fame?

I totally agree with this induction. - 60%

I am fine with this induction. - 0%

I do not agree with this induction, but it does not bother me. - 0%

No opinion. - 0%

Kick him out! - 40%

OTTAWA SENATORS VS. TORONTO MAPLE LEAFS

Mar 21, 2026

Buy your Tickets to see Ottawa Senators vs. Toronto Maple Leafs HERE!

Canadian Tire Centre Kanata, ON

NEW YORK RANGERS VS. OTTAWA SENATORS

Mar 23, 2026

Buy your Tickets to see New York Rangers vs. Ottawa Senators HERE!

Madison Square Garden New York, NY