For a song called “Stay” it was a song that didn’t “stay” on the radio once it began playing marking it the shortest song in duration (clocking in at 1:39) to reach number one on the Top 100.
Maurice Williams and the Zodiacs are regarded as a one hit wonder, that isn’t exactly the case as under a previous name (The Gladiolas) the group went #11 in 1957 with “Little Darlin’”, a song that would become more famous when covered by The Diamonds a year later and become their signature song. The South Carolina based band would allegedly change their name to the Zodiacs (though would later change personnel) upon seeing a Ford Zodiac when their own car broke down.
Williams and his trademarked falsetto crowed for his girl just to “stay a little bit longer”, and the simple message with the up tempo delivery resonated well with the audience and with the R&B/Doo Wop still going strong there was a reason to believe that Maurice Williams and the Zodiacs would “Stay” in the public eye a little longer.
The group would have two more minor hits but they would not have another large song and would quickly be a part of the oldies circuit.
That’s it; I have no more puns on the word “stay”.
Other Notable Songs that charted but did not go to number one in this time period: November 21, 1960 – November 27, 1960.
11/21/60: Hucklebuck by Chubby Checker went to #14 but also went to #15 on the R&B Chart.
 This might be one of those rare times where being referred to as a “Zodiac” wasn’t so bad. There was the Zodiac killer after all and a million masked bad guy wrestlers named the “Zodiac”.
 I know, I know…It was bad enough I used the title as a pun once already. To do it twice is inexcusable.