After the 1996 World Junior Hockey Tournament where he led Canada to their fourth straight Gold Medal, Jose Theodore, who was drafted by the Montreal Canadiens would slowly work his way up the organization’s depth chart and in the 1999-2000 he would share netminding duties before becoming the main Goalie shortly after.
Jason Arnott played 1,244 Games with 938 Points and had over 100 Point Shares, all of which are impressive but it might make him the ultimate “compiler” as he was never considered an elite player and was an All Star only twice. Beyond being the runner up for the Calder in 1994, he never received any consideration for any award as the highest he came was a 29th place finish for the Selke in 2004.