Not In: All In (42)

Kirk Buchner and Robert Dobek dive deep into one of baseball’s most enduring debates: Should Pete Rose and Shoeless Joe Jackson be inducted into the Hall of Fame? With MLB lifting bans on 18 individuals, the conversation expands into the ethics of legacy, the steroid era, MVP controversies, and how Hall of Fame standards vary across sports.

In this fiery episode of Not In: All In, Kirk Buchner, Chris Mouradian, and Dave Whitlock take aim at MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred’s proposed realignment plan—and they don’t hold back. From breaking up historic rivalries to expansion chaos, the crew dissects every angle with humor, insight, and a few nostalgic tangents.

Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian dive into the seismic shift in sports media as the NFL acquires a stake in ESPN. Is this the end of objective football journalism? The duo also roast Disney’s handling of its franchises, praise the evolution of NFL kickers, and unpack Malik Beasley’s financial troubles. Plus, they celebrate the Tkachuk family’s hockey legacy and Alex Palou’s IndyCar dominance. It’s a wild ride through sports, media, and controversy—with a few laughs and hot takes along the way.

In this powerful and personal episode of Not in: All In, Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian get real about iconic losses, wild sports takes, and the shifting landscape of athletics. Kirk reflects on Hulk Hogan’s controversial legacy following news of his death, and Chris drops a jaw-dropping hot take: Major League Baseball should contract six teams! The duo also dive into the WNBA’s struggles with fame vs. financial viability and the treatment of Caitlin Clark.

Welcome to Season 1, Episode 12 of Not in: All In! Kirk Buchner, Chris Mouradian, and Dave Whitlock dive deep into the 2025 MLB All-Star Game selections, sharing their takes on who deserved a spot, who didn't, and what this means for potential Hall of Fame legacies. From Cal Raleigh's home run chase to Aaron Judge's MVP trajectory and the curious case of Tyreek Skubal’s Cy Young path, it's an unfiltered, passionate conversation that spans decades of baseball fandom.

In Episode 10 of Not In: All In, Kirk Buchner, Dave Whitlock, and Chris Mouradian dig into the Caitlin Clark WNBA controversy and broader issues around support in women’s sports. The trio doesn’t shy away from heated debate—race, rivalry, media narratives, and missed opportunities in the WNBA all come to the fore.

Join Kirk Buchner, Chris Mouradian, and Dave Whitlock in another episode of Not In, All In! where we dive deep into the NBA Finals matchup between Oklahoma City Thunder and Indiana Pacers, plus the NHL Stanley Cup rematch featuring Edmonton Oilers vs. Florida Panthers. Who’s got the edge? Who needs a breakout performance? And will the ratings shock the league?

Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian return for Episode 6 of Not In: All In!, bringing their usual mix of analysis, humor, and unfiltered sports takes.

? Major Topics:
? NHL Playoffs Final Four – Can Connor McDavid finally capture a Stanley Cup? Will the Maple Leafs’ latest collapse lead to a complete rebuild?
⚾ PED Suspensions Shake MLB – José Alvarado and Jurickson Profar banned for 80 games—what’s behind the numbers?
? NBA Conference Finals – Brunson, Edwards, SGA, or Haliburton—who will become the NBA’s next superstar?
? Indy 500 Qualifiers – Robert Shwartzman shocks the racing world with a pole position in his rookie season.

The guys bring insight, hot takes, and deep dives into the biggest sports stories of the week!

Welcome to Episode 4 of Not in Hall of Fame's All In! ?️ Kirk Buchner leads a dynamic panel featuring Chris Mouradian, Dave Whitlock, and Paul Lawrence as they tackle the latest headlines and controversies across sports.

? Key Topics Covered in This Episode:

1️⃣ Shannon Sharpe’s Legal Battle – The panel weighs in on Shannon’s public controversy, discussing the fallout, its implications for his Pro Football Hall of Fame induction, and whether this situation can be salvaged.
2️⃣ Shedeur Sanders’ NFL Draft Journey – A fascinating discussion on the unprecedented draft slide, the impact of Deion Sanders’ influence, and Shedeur’s road to redemption with the Cleveland Browns.
3️⃣ Hockey vs. NBA Playoffs – Comparing the excitement levels and narratives surrounding hockey’s thrilling matchups and the NBA’s struggles to deliver compelling playoff stories.

Kirk and the team combine thoughtful analysis, sharp critiques, and lively banter for a sports talk experience like no other!

Welcome to Episode 2 of Not in All In! Kirk Buchner, joined by Chris Mouradian and Texas sports expert Dave Whitlock, dives deep into two electrifying topics—Rory McIlroy’s monumental Grand Slam victory and the ever-controversial NCAA NIL system.