Yes, we know that this is taking a while!

As many of you know, we at Notinhalloffame.com are slowly generating the top 50 of each major North American sports team. That being said, we maintain and update our existing Top 50 lists annually.  We are pleased to present our pre-2026 revision of our top 50 Toronto Blue Jays.

As for all of our top 50 players in baseball, we look at the following: 

1.  Duration and Impact.

2.  Traditional statistics and how they finished in Major League Baseball.

3.  Advanced Statistics.

4.  Playoff performance.

5. Their respective legacy on the team.

6. How successful the team was when he was there.

7. Respecting the era in which they played.

Criteria 1-4 will make up the lion’s share of the algorithm.  Please note that we have implemented this for the first time.  This has changed the rankings all throughout the board.

Last year, the Toronto Blue Jays shocked the baseball world with an unexpected run to the World Series, falling to the heavily favored Los Angeles Dodgers in seven games.  There were two new entrants and two elevations as per last year’s season.

As always, we present our top five, which saw one change based on the new algorithm.

1. Dave Stieb
2. Roy Halladay
3. Jose Bautista
4. Carlos Delgado
5. Tony Fernandez

You can find the entire list here.

Within the top five, Carlos Delgado and Tony Fernandez flipped the #4 and #5 spots.

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. rocketed up from #12 to #6.

Bo Bichette, who is now a New York Met, moved up from #27 to #22.

Outfielder George Springer debuted at #34.

Pitcher Kevin Gausman debuted at #35.

We thank you for your continued support of our lists on Notinhalloffame.com.

When Kevin Gausman signed a five-year, $110 million deal with the Toronto Blue Jays before the 2022 season, he had a clear, high-stakes goal: to fill the role left by Cy Young winner Robbie Ray and provide the team with a reliable, top-tier pitcher. Ray was known for his unpredictable, high-energy style, while Gausman offers a very different presence—calm, precise, with a focus on a deceptive four-seam fastball and an almost unhittable splitter, which has become one of baseball's most formidable pitches. Over his first four seasons with Toronto, this right-handed pitcher has significantly transformed the Blue Jays' pitching identity.

His early years in Canada showcased elite run suppression and advanced metrics. Gausman quickly overcame any transition hurdles, establishing himself at the top of the rotation with an impressive 2.35 FIP (Fielding Independent Pitching) in 2022, demonstrating his world-class efficiency. In 2023, he reached an even higher level, leading the American League with 237 strikeouts. His outstanding performance earned him an All-Star selection, a spot on the All-MLB Second Team, and a third-place finish in the AL Cy Young voting, solidifying his popularity at Rogers Centre.

Despite a frustrating 2024 campaign marked by minor physical setbacks and typical statistical decline, Gausman demonstrated remarkable resilience, paving the way for a strong and durable rebound in the 2025 season. He consistently took the mound with unwavering reliability, serving as the dependable veteran leader for an assertive Blue Jays team that fought their way into October baseball. His season highlight was an exceptional performance on September 11 against Houston, where he pitched a two-hit complete game shutout using only 100 pitches and achieved a historic 79% strike rate, setting new modern organizational records.

Gausman carried that momentum into a deep 2025 postseason, guiding Toronto to a thrilling seven-game World Series against the Los Angeles Dodgers. Acting as a true October ace, he made six appearances—five starts—and pitched 30.2 innings, setting a new franchise record for postseason innings. Gausman dominated top lineups with a remarkable 2.93 ERA and a 0.91 WHIP, limiting opponents to a .159 batting average. His outstanding performance included a classic 8-strikeout game in the World Series, where he matched historic MLB records by striking out all eight batters in the first three innings.

Gausman enters 2026 on the final season of his deal, and he is looking to bring the Jays back to the playoffs.