The Right Wing had his first 50-Point season in 2015-16, his debut campaign as a Devil. Palmieri hit that feat in 2016-17 and 2018-19, the latter of which securing him his first trip to the All-Star Game. As a Devil. Palmieri had three 50-plus Point years, and though none of those years cracked 60 Points, it was still by far the best run of his career. As good as he was, the struggling Devils traded him to the surging Islanders late in the 2020/21 Season.
As a Devil, Palmieri accumulated 266 Points.