This one should be a little interesting.
There was a time when Tim Lincecum was considered the best Pitcher in the National League and rightfully so. Dubbed “The Freak” due to his powerful arm despite having a slender frame, Linceum is one of the few hurlers to record back-to-back Cy Youngs (2008 & 2009) in a stretch where he would also lead the National League both seasons in Strikeouts, FIP and SO/9. Lincecum would still receive Cy Young votes over the next two seasons but injuries would render him a fraction of what he was and realistically Lincecum was a player with two excellent seasons, two very good seasons, and a few horrible ones, the latter two of which was when he would become a three time World Series Champion.
This one should be interesting.
In a different time, Ryan Howard would receive serious Baseball Hall of Fame consideration. Howard was a fear power hitter who won the Rookie of the Year in 2005 and followed that up with a 58 Home Run and 149 RBI season (both league leading) not to mention a Slash Line of .312/.425/.659 that netted him the National League MVP. The next three seasons would see Howard belt over 40 and he would have two more of 30 and also would have two more RBI Titles. More importantly he helped the Phillies win the World Series in 2009 and he was named the NLCS MVP that year.