Claude Provost is the answer to a few unwanted trivia questions. He is currently the man whose name is etched on the Stanley Cup Trophy the most times without being in the Hockey Hall of Fame. He also has the most All-Star appearances of any non-Hall of Fame Member. It could be because Claude Provost was primarily a checker (though about as good as they came) and maybe because he was on a star studded Montreal Canadians dynasty that he got forgotten by the Hall. Though he was on those outstanding Habs teams, Provost was a key part of that success and earned all of his names on Lord Stanley’s Mug; all nine of them.

As part of Buffalo’s vaunted “French Connection” line, Rick Martin was part of the most exciting lines in hockey in the 1970s. Martin was a lethal sniper and once he mastered his defensive skills was one of the better two-way players in hockey. With two 50 goal seasons (not exactly easy in the ’70s) and as a perennial All-Star, Martin should have enjoyed some success in the ’80s and have a steady decline into his 30’s the way most star players do. Sadly, a brutal injury in November of 1980 essentially put an end to his career, and he only played a handful of games after. Had Rick Martin made it through at least a few of the free-wheeling 80’s, his career stats would have likely been padded sufficiently to make the Hall. Currently, he remains one of the top stars of the 70’s on the outside looking in.

With 477 career NHL points (and 283 in the WHA), the professional statistics speak to a very good player, but not that of a Hall of Famer. This is very much the consensus of most hockey pundits and fans alike. However, we are all familiar with the intangible legacy of the 1972 Canada/Soviet Union Summit Series. Coming off his most productive NHL year with 38 goals, Henderson was an afterthought selection to Team Canada. Henderson responded with the best hockey of his career, leading the tournament with ten points. Of course, it was that final point, a goal with thirty-four seconds remaining, that he will be known forever for. That goal won the series and made him an icon in Canada. It is a moment that is played over and over again on Canadian television and will be replayed for generations to come. When critics say that Paul Henderson would not be in the Hall of Fame discussion if he hadn’t scored “the goal,” but what they have to remember is one thing: HE DID score that goal.