Not in Hall of Fame If it's not in the Hall of Fame, it's at Not in Hall of Fame

2023 Fictitious Athlete Hall of Fame - Round 1

Gus Matthews

TV Show/Movie Appeared: The Benchwarmers (2006)
Actor/Actress: Rob Schneider
Position Portrayed: Multiple
Played For:: The Benchwarmers
Why you should vote:: He successfully dominated on the baseball diamond…..
Why you should not vote:: ……against pre-teens.
Two major things work against the Benchwarmers. First, is that we are asked to believe that Rob Schneider (AKA: the guy who played Deuce Bigelow and the annoying copy guy on SNL) is a Baseball star. The second thing is that watching grown men, regardless of physically inept they are, defeating a bunch of kids on the baseball diamond is rewarding for the viewer in any capacity.