B.J. Surhoff joined Milwaukee in 1987 as the top overall pick from the 1985 draft, a highly regarded prospect known for his unique blend of college success and defensive skill. Although he reached the height of his statistics in Baltimore later on, he spent almost ten years with the Brewers, where he was a key contact hitter and an important part of the team’s lineup.

In 1987, Surhoff hit a remarkable milestone for a rookie catcher by batting .299 and playing a key role in igniting the team's memorable 13-0 start to the season. He demonstrated an impressive mastery of the strike zone right from the beginning, earning a reputation as one of the most challenging outs in the American League. Although he was initially drafted as a catcher, he showed incredible versatility by eventually playing at third base and in the outfield.

Between 1988 and 1991, Surhoff was a key catcher, playing over 125 games each season. He displayed excellent strike zone control, never striking out more than 49 times annually. In 1990, he hit a peak in situational hitting, stealing 18 bases and hitting 21 doubles. 

In 1992, the organization started to shift behind the plate. While he remained a key player, with 121 hits and helping Milwaukee vie for the AL East title until the final weekend, he also began to make a special move across the diamond. By 1993, he had become remarkably versatile, taking on the role of the team's main third baseman. That year, he delivered a remarkable display of resilience. After a slow start, he soared to a career-high 38 doubles and 79 RBIs, earning the Brewers' Unsung Hero Award for his smooth transition to the hot corner.

After the 1995 season, Surhoff departed for Baltimore as a free agent.  He batted .274 with 1,064 hits for the Blue Brew Crew.