gold star for USAHOF

Should Boomer Esiason be in the Hall of Fame?


Statistics:

Definitely put him in!
Votes: 276
66.5%  
Maybe, but others deserve it first.
Votes: 62
14.9%  
Probably not, but it wouldn't be the end of the world.
Votes: 41
9.9%  
No opinion.
Votes: 2
0.5%  
No way!
Votes: 34
8.2%  

Number of Voters   415
Start Voting   2012-04-24 02:50:41
End Voting   2030-05-24 02:50:41

Comments   

+1 #3 Katrina 2018-02-06 03:20
Honestly, he's an NFL MVP! For all the players who come and go there aren't that many MVP's and Boomer is one. He brought the Bengals to a Super Bowl. He is a Walter Peyton Award Recipient and he continues to partake in so many positive ways for the NFL. Represents all that is good as a player and a man. And others would not have as successful careers without him. HE made other players better. He absolutely belongs in the Hall.
Quote
+1 #2 Mr. Dunwich 2017-06-26 23:42
The problem with Boomer is that he only truly had about 4 seasons which we can consider very good or great. The remaining 2/3rds of his career though he was merely adequate.
For much of his career, he simply wasn't a highly productive QB in terms of creating volume. So much so, that after the 1990 season he failed to throw more than 17 TD's in any season (91-97).
I will readily admit that he was a great QB overall, under Sam Wyche from 85 through 89, but beyond that his career wasn't impressive.
Another "No" for HoF induction
Quote
0 #1 CHRISTOPHER PAPPAS 2012-09-12 16:57
:-) I am trying compile a lot friends, family members, and especially “sports writers”, which they ultimately matter to induct All Pro Quarterback “Boomer Esiason” who played 14 seasons in the NFL Hall of Fame. I talked to Boomer today (9/12/12) and told him personally I want nothing in return, because I respect the man as a Football player, Broadcaster, and as Family man.
This is also coming from a man (me), who lives and breathes” NY Giants Football,” but I am a realistic fan. So therefore I have put together a few other Quarterbacks who are in the NFL Hall of Fame, whom deserve to be (which I respect as well) and they are as follows: “Jim Kelly, Steve Young, Troy Aikman, and finally (and I know I am going to catch a lot of heat for saying this one,) and that is Dan Marino
:-)
Quote

Add comment

Security code
Refresh