In the 1890’s, Billy Rhines would have two three year runs with the Cincinnati Reds (1890-92 & 1895-97).  In each stint, he would win an Earned Run Average Title and WHIP Title.  Basically, Rhines had one excellent season in each of his stints as a Red and he is easily one of the better hurlers the team has ever had.  Those two years are enough to rank him here.

Overall as a Red, Rhines had a record of 96-79 with a 3.28 ERA.

Perhaps a strange entry considering his relatively low tenure as a Cincinnati Red, Cy Seymour put together one of the finest and undervalued seasons in the early 1900’s.

Come on now, You didn’t think we were finished talking about the “Big Red Machine” from the mid 70’s did you?

With the exception of six Games at the end of his career with the California Angels, Gary Nolan was with Cincinnati for his entire career assisting them to consecutive World Series titles in the 70’s.