While Gordon “Red” Berenson would win a Stanley Cup with the Montreal Canadiens in 1965, he really did not have much to do with that title. Unable to find a permanent spot on their roster, he would be traded to the New York Rangers. Still, it was when he was traded to the expansion St. Louis Blues in the 1967-68 season that he would not just find a place in the professional ranks but in a starring capacity.
While he was in the shadow (and actually played in it) of his big brother, “The Big M” Frank Mahovolich, Pete Mahovolich was quite the player in his own right.
Claude Lemieux was known for being a playoff superstar, which he was! He is currently fourth all-time in Playoff Games, and he scored 158 Points in those postseason contests. Lemieux is one of only ten players to have captured the Stanley Cup with three different teams (Montreal, New Jersey, and Colorado). He is a former Conn Smythe Trophy winner, and he was the leading goal scorer in the playoffs twice. Clearly, Lemieux saved his best for when it counted, but in his 1,215 career games, he scored 786 Points, which is also pretty good.