gold star for USAHOF

Do the Oilers Have a Chance of Winning the Cup After Two Consecutive Finals Losses?

Do the Oilers Have a Chance of Winning the Cup After Two Consecutive Finals Losses?
28 Oct
2025
Not in Hall of Fame

Edmonton enters the 2025-26 NHL season carrying the weight of two straight Stanley Cup Final defeats. The question facing the franchise, its fans, and the betting public remains straightforward: can this team finally break through? Current evidence from bookmakers, statistical models, and market behavior suggests the answer leans toward yes.

The Numbers Behind Edmonton's Favoritism

Sportsbooks across North America have positioned the Oilers at the top of their Stanley Cup futures boards. Covers lists them at +640, making them the outright favorite ahead of Carolina at +750 and Colorado at +850. BetMGM places Edmonton at +775, while ESPN BET and Bleacher Report both offer +850. These odds translate to an implied probability between 10 and 14 percent, which ranks unusually high in a league containing 32 teams.

Statistical models paint an even more optimistic picture. Moneypuck's advanced analytics assign Edmonton an 84.8 percent chance of making the playoffs and a 51.8 percent probability of reaching the Stanley Cup Final. Both figures lead the league as of October 27, 2025. The Jets trail at 81.6 percent and 42.2 percent, respectively, while the Capitals sit at 80.7 percent and 42.4 percent.

Betting Markets React to Oilers' Championship Push

The Oilers' position as Stanley Cup favorites has created notable movement across betting platforms in Alberta and beyond. Local sportsbooks report increased wagering volume on Edmonton futures, with bet365 and Sports Interaction adjusting their lines from +800 to +750 in response to heavy action. BetVictor and Betway have followed suit, while platforms featured on Covers' list of betting apps in Alberta show similar patterns of line movement favoring the Oilers.

Sharp money continues backing Edmonton despite their slow offensive start this season. Professional bettors are capitalizing on the value before odds shorten further, particularly after Florida's Barkov injury and Vegas dealing with Mark Stone's absence. The consensus among betting syndicates suggests the current +640 to +850 range won't last long if Edmonton maintains their health advantage over conference rivals.

Early Season Struggles Follow Familiar Pattern

Edmonton's offensive production has started poorly this season. The team ranks fourth-worst in goals per 60 minutes at five-on-five with 1.6, and ties Nashville for fourth-fewest goals per game at 2.5. This mirrors their pattern from previous seasons when slow regular season starts gave way to dominant playoff performances.

The power play and penalty kill units have performed below expectations through the first month. Special teams efficiency typically determines playoff success, and Edmonton's coaching staff will need to address these deficiencies before April. Their ability to overcome similar starts in past seasons provides some reassurance, though relying on late-season surges carries inherent risks.

Health Advantages Over Key Competitors

Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl remain healthy and productive, providing Edmonton with the league's most dangerous offensive duo. The team's defensive corps and goaltending tandem have avoided major injuries through October, contrasting sharply with several championship contenders.

Florida faces an extended absence from captain Aleksander Barkov, who suffered torn ACL and MCL ligaments. Vegas continues managing Mark Stone's wrist injury on a week-to-week basis. Colorado has dealt with defensive injuries that have disrupted their early season structure. Edmonton's relative health provides them with a roster stability that eluded them during portions of previous campaigns.

The McDavid Factor and Supporting Cast Questions

McDavid's performance level continues to exceed standard superstar production. His ability to control games during playoff series has been established through two Finals runs. Draisaitl provides elite secondary scoring that few teams can match. The question becomes who steps forward from the supporting cast when opponents focus their defensive schemes on neutralizing these two players.

Goaltending remains Edmonton's most scrutinized position. The team lacks a proven elite netminder comparable to what Florida, Tampa Bay, or the Rangers possess. Their approach relies on committee goaltending and outscoring opponents in high-scoring affairs. This strategy has taken them to consecutive Finals but failed at the final hurdle both times.

Pacific Division and Western Conference Positioning

Edmonton holds favorite status to win the Pacific Division at +170, which implies roughly 40 percent probability. Their Western Conference futures sit at +400, placing them among the top two choices to emerge from the West. The Pacific Division lacks another legitimate Cup contender, with Vegas dealing with injuries and Seattle, Los Angeles, and Calgary all showing limitations.

The broader Western Conference presents more formidable challenges. Colorado's championship pedigree and Dallas's consistent excellence create potential roadblocks. Winnipeg's strong start and Minnesota's depth could complicate Edmonton's path. Still, bookmakers and models favor Edmonton's chances over these competitors.

What Makes This Season Different

Two factors distinguish this season from Edmonton's previous Finals appearances. First, key Western Conference rivals face more substantial roster challenges than in recent years. Second, the betting market's confidence in Edmonton has reached unprecedented levels, with sharp bettors backing the Oilers at higher volumes than previous seasons.

The team's leadership group has gained valuable Finals experience through their recent losses. Young players have matured into reliable contributors. Management avoided major roster disruption during the offseason, maintaining chemistry while making targeted depth additions.

Conclusion

Edmonton's championship odds reflect both their proven ability to reach the Finals and lingering doubts about their capacity to win four games against elite competition in June. The betting market's assessment, ranging from +640 to +850, positions them as the league's top contender. Statistical models support this evaluation, projecting Edmonton's path to the Finals as more probable than any competitor.

Their early offensive struggles follow established patterns that have not prevented previous playoff success. The health advantages over Florida and Vegas provide immediate value. McDavid and Draisaitl remain elite performers capable of carrying the team through difficult series.

The Oilers possess legitimate championship credentials. Market sentiment, analytical projections, and roster construction all point toward a third consecutive Finals appearance. Converting that opportunity into Edmonton's first Stanley Cup since 1990 will require solving the final-round puzzle that has twice proven beyond their reach.

Tagged under
Committee Chairman

Kirk Buchner, "The Committee Chairman", is the owner and operator of the site.  Kirk can be contacted at [email protected] .

Comments powered by CComment