Playing his entire career with the New York Mets, David Wright would become one of the better Third Baseman in his time in baseball.

Wright debuted in 2004, and he had his first of what would be seven All-Star Games in 2006.  Wright showed power with six 20-home-run years, speed with three 20-SB seasons, and a great batting eye with seven years over .300. He had the offensive stats and was an above-average defensive player who earned two Gold Gloves.

Wright retired with 1,777 Hits, a .296 Batting Average, and 242 Home Runs.  He could be a fringe candidate to advance to a second ballot, but regardless, he is among the leaders in every Mets offensive category.

Playing all ten of his seasons in baseball with the Baltimore Orioles, Chris Tillman had five years where he was a solid rotation pitcher with the team (2012-16). 

Chase Utley came up through the Philadelphia Phillies system, and after debuting in 2003, he would quickly become the heart of a team that would win the 2008 World Series.

The Second Baseman brought a lot to the table, and from 2006 to 2010, he was a perennial All-Star.  In three of those seasons, Utley finished in the top ten in MVP voting, and he was a Silver Slugger in four of them.  From 2005 to 2009, he would have at least 22 Home Runs, with the first four of them seeing him hit the three-digit mark in Runs Batted In.  He also had two .300 years in that time frame.  Utley did not steal the most bases, but when he did, he was rarely caught.  As of this writing, he is second all-time in Stolen Base Percentage.  He also sacrificed his body to get on base.  He led the NL in Hit By Pitch three years in a row (2007-09), and he is in the top ten all-time.

Defensively, Utley never won a Gold Glove, but he certainly should have been considered for several.  He had five seasons with a Defensive bWAR over 2.0. 

Utley would go to one final All-Star in 2014, and he would finish his career with a few seasons in Los Angeles with the Dodgers, where he provided veteran leadership.  He retired in 2019 with 1,885 Hits with 259 Home Runs.

Chase Headley was a switch-hitting Third Baseman, whose career was spent mostly with the San Diego Padres.