Andy Pettitte took PEDs and apologized for it. He was forgiven by not just the fans of the New York Yankees but baseball fans in general. That fact (an important one) makes him the most intriguing candidate for this year as his contriteness might make him Hall of Fame worthy.
Still, if the PED issue is not a factor, is Andy Pettitte an HOF contender? Let’s take a look!
While Pettitte was only an All Star three times, he was a top five finisher in Cy Young voting four times and retired with 256 Wins and 2,448 Strikeouts. That is good, but with the exceptions of leading the American League in Wins in 1996, and HR/9 in 1997 he never led his league in any pitching category, be it traditional or sabremetric. Pettitte does have a 19 and 11 post season record and five World Series Rings, but his playoff numbers are only marginally better that his regular season ones, though it should be pointed out that he won the ALCS MVP in 2001.
Andy Pettitte is definitely a bubble candidate though which side of the bubble is very much open for debate.
Should Andy Pettitte be in the Hall of Fame?
Definitely put him in! - 37.9%
Maybe, but others deserve it first. - 27.6%
Probably not, but it wouldn't be the end of the world. - 6.9%