- Published in Top 50 Toronto Blue Jays
49. Jose Cruz
Jose Cruz came from a baseball pedigree as the son of the Astros star of the same name. Also playing in the Outfield, the younger Cruz went to the Jays from Seattle as a rookie, and though there were high hopes for Cruz, the Mariners dealt him for pitching help in their playoff run. He finished the year as the American League runner-up for the Rookie of the Year with a 26 HR year.
Cruz looked poised for greatness after his rookie year, but the next two seasons, it did not come to fruition, with Cruz missing Games due to injury with diminished power numbers (25 HR in 211 Games) with a Batting Average barely scraping .250. His next two years were much better, belting 31 and 34 Home Runs, respectively, but with the exception of 2001, his OPS never breached .800, though he was a 30-30 player that year. He regressed again in 2002 and left for the Giants after as a Free Agent.
Cruz might have disappointed, but he did manage to belt 122 Home Runs with 640 Hits as a Blue Jay, which is more than many can claim.