Menu
A+ A A-
Committee Chairman

Committee Chairman

Kirk Buchner, "The Committee Chairman", is the owner and operator of the site.  Kirk can be contacted at [email protected] .

3. Christy Mathewson

Mastery over a single era is rare in professional sports, but the early 20th-century baseball scene was dominated by Christopher Mathewson's elegant style. As the quintessential modern pitching staff anchor, this right-hander had a legendary, mysterious repertoire centered around his “fadeaway”, a screwball that sharply broke inward against right-handed batters. However, his journey to legendary status nearly faltered before it really began. The New York Giants signed him from the minor leagues in 1900, but a poor initial showing led management to send him back to Norfolk. The Cincinnati Reds quickly claimed him that winter, but the Giants quickly corrected their error by executing a dramatic trade to bring him back to Manhattan. This remains one of the most remarkable organizational turnaround stories in sports history.

Mathewson quickly responded to the team's sudden shift in stance by refining his early stats and then delivered a remarkable 1903 season, finishing with a 30–13 record and leading the National League with 267 strikeouts. He followed this with an even more impressive 33-win season in 1904, earning another strikeout title and leading a strong pitching staff that won the National League pennant. Sadly, ongoing political conflicts between Giants owner John T.. Brush and the management of the American League's Boston Americans led to New York boycotting the postseason, depriving Mathewson of a chance at a world championship.

That injustice was brief, as the 1905 season became his definitive hardware-certified masterpiece. Mathewson achieved the rare Pitcher’s Triple Crown by leading the Senior Circuit in wins (31), ERA (1.28), and strikeouts (206), guiding the Giants back to the ultimate stage. This time, they did not fall short; in the 1905 World Series against the Philadelphia Athletics, Mathewson delivered one of the most remarkable postseason performances ever, pitching three complete-game shutouts within six days to win the franchise's first world championship.

Far from a short-lived peak, he turned run prevention into a strict, daily regular-season routine for the remainder of the decade. Mathewson secured a second Pitcher's Triple Crown during a staggering 1908 showcase, racking up a modern franchise-record 37 victories alongside a microscopic 1.43 ERA and 259 punchouts. He followed that up by capturing the 1909 National League ERA efficiency title with a sparkling 1.14 mark, systematically paralyzing opposing batting orders through an elite mix of movement and unshakeable poise.

As the 1910s approached and natural wear affected his speed, Mathewson shifted to a more controlled style. He compensated for the loss of his top velocity by enhancing his spatial awareness and strike-zone judgment, winning two more National League ERA titles in 1911 and 1913.

His accuracy reached an almost mythical baseline, as he led the Senior Circuit in fewest walks per nine innings for five consecutive summers from 1911 through 1915, anchoring his legacy as the ultimate mound maestro. He propelled New York to three consecutive National League pennants from 1911 to 1913, but despite throwing his heart out across all three Fall Classics, a lack of defensive support and anemic run-production from his teammates left the Giants frustrated casualties in all three series.

By the 1916 campaign, the heavy structural toll of his massive career workload finally caught up to him, leaving his legendary arm a shell of its former self. Recognizing that the organizational relationship had reached its definitive career exit, the front office traded the veteran icon back to the Cincinnati Reds, where he immediately transitioned into a player-manager role, making just one final sentimental pitching appearance before walking away from the rubber for good.

He is the all-time franchise leader in bWAR for Pitchers (100.6), ERA (2.12), Wins (372), Innings Pitched (4,779.2), and Strikeouts (2,504).  Mathewson was elected into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1936 as part of the first Hall of Fame Class.  The Giants honored Mathewson by naming the stadium after him and placing his name and an "NY" alongside the other retired numbers.

2. Barry Bonds

Creating a historical hierarchy for a Major League franchise involves delicately separating pure individual performance from the often polarizing public opinion. This is particularly challenging when evaluating Barry Bonds. When he arrived in Northern California before the 1993 season, he was already a two-time National League MVP and a superstar with the Pittsburgh Pirates. However, what he achieved over the next 15 years under the bay winds goes beyond typical statistics. With an incredibly compact, high-velocity swing and a nearly telepathic sense of the strike zone, Bonds transformed the batter's box into a laboratory of offensive mastery, reaching a peak that redefined the sport’s physics.

The subsequent stretch from 1994 through 1999 cemented his standing as the premier five-tool weapon in professional baseball, even as external forces began shifting the sport's landscape. During the strike-shortened 1994 calendar, Bonds refused to let the labor stoppage halt his elite consistency, batting .312 with 37 home runs and a league-leading 74 walks in just 112 games to secure a fourth-place finish in the MVP voting. He backed that up in 1995 by crossing the century mark in runs batted in once again, lashing 33 home runs and driving home 104 runs despite a down year for the club's overall offense.

His absolute physical peak of the decade erupted during a magnificent 1996 showcase. Bonds put on an unadulterated display of historical, multi-dimensional artistry, exploding for 42 home runs while drawing a spectacular, league-leading 151 walks to fuel a massive .461 on-base percentage. Showing he was still a lethal, high-velocity engine on the basepaths, he swiped 40 bases to become only the second player in major league history to register a 40-home run, 40-stolen base season—joining Jose Canseco and matching the deep, versatile athletic bloodline of his father, Bobby Bonds.

He maintained that hardware-certified authority through the late 1990s, capturing consecutive Gold Gloves and Silver Sluggers across the 1997 and 1998 campaigns. The 1997 season saw him crush 40 homers and drive in 101 runs to carry the Giants back to the postseason, while his 1998 run secured his place in the record books as the founding, lone member of the mythical 400-home run, 400-stolen base club. Yet, despite his relentless excellence, the sport was rapidly fracturing around him; the game was evolving into a high-scoring, muscle-bound era where rival sluggers were visibly altering their physiques and dominating national headlines with astronomical home run totals.

Following an injury-shortened 1999 campaign where a bone spur in his elbow limited him to 102 games—though he still managed a robust 34 home runs—Bonds returned to the rubber with a transformed frame and a fierce competitive chip on his shoulder. At age 35, his body appeared to be changing, and any remaining doubts that his game had entered a completely detached, supernatural dimension were permanently shattered during a historic 2001 regular-season masterpiece.

The 2001 campaign stands as the absolute structural zenith of individual dominance in baseball history. Bonds put on an unbelievable display of offensive violence, shattering Mark McGwire’s single-season record by launching a breathtaking 73 home runs. He walked away with his fourth career MVP, and regardless of the growing skepticism from national writers or the vitriol directed at him from opposing fans, he established himself as the most feared offensive entity to ever look at a baseball. Opposing managers completely abandoned traditional tactical logic, treating him with an unprecedented level of caution that frequently resulted in him being intentionally walked even with the bases loaded.

What followed from 2001 through 2004 was a four-year run of hitting success that will likely never be replicated as long as the sport exists. Bonds turned run production into a strict, everyday routine, sweeping four consecutive National League Most Valuable Player Awards while leading the major leagues in on-base percentage, slugging percentage, and OPS every single summer. His advanced efficiency filters reached a comical peak during the 2004 schedule, where he batted a blistering .362 and drew an astronomical, record-shattering 232 walks—including 120 intentional free passes—to post a mind-bending .609 on-base percentage.

As natural physical wear and tear and severe knee issues mounted in the post-2004 twilight of his career, Bonds became increasingly injured, yet his internal efficiency filters remained completely unstoppable whenever he could hobble up to the plate. He continued to pass historic milestones on a regular basis, ultimately surpassing Hank Aaron on August 7, 2007, to secure the sport’s ultimate career crown. Following the expiration of his contract at the conclusion of that 2007 schedule, the front office officially signaled a structural transition, and with a cloud of legal scrutiny and corporate blackballing hovering over his name, no other major league club offered him an opportunity to extend his journey.

Following his contract's expiry, neither the Giants nor any other club offered him an opportunity.  He would retire, belting 586 Home Runs, 1,440 RBI, and recording a Slash Line of .312/.477/.666 for San Francisco.

Controversy or not, there will never be another hitter like Barry Bonds again.

The Baseball Hall of Fame may never call his name, but the Giants inducted him into their Wall of Fame in 2017.

1. Willie Mays

In discussions concerning the highest attainable level of human athletic achievement, baseball analysts often categorize performance into five distinct tools: batting for average, power hitting, speed on the bases, defensive glove work, and arm strength. While numerous distinguished players excel in two or three of these areas, Willie Mays not only possessed all five attributes but also demonstrated them with transcendent, high-velocity artistry that permanently expanded the boundaries of what is considered possible in the sport. Prior to donning the renowned black-and-orange uniform, the young prodigy from Alabama spent two foundational seasons with the Birmingham Black Barons of the Negro American League, showcasing a remarkable raw skill set that compelled Major League scouts to contact their offices urgently. When the New York Giants ultimately secured his contract, they did more than acquire an elite center fielder; they gained the

From the moment he made his major league debut in 1951, Mays served as a pivotal catalyst for team success. Entering the major leagues as a charismatic twenty-year-old, he transformed simple batting performance into an extraordinary display, inspiring a legendary team spirit that notably rallied from a significant 13.5-game deficit in August to secure the National League pennant. While his batting average was a modest .274 with 20 home runs, his remarkable defensive range and relentless energy earned him the National League Rookie of the Year accolade. Just as his career was ascending rapidly, he was called to serve; military obligations in the U.S. Army caused him to miss nearly the entire 1952 and 1953 seasons. Nevertheless, rather than allowing this enforced hiatus to impede his progress, his return to active duty in 1954 marked a vigorous and multifaceted resurgence in the sport.

The 1954 campaign exemplifies a definitive mastery in individual performance and postseason execution. Leading the lineup with substantial authority, Mays secured the National League batting title with an impressive .345 average and hit 41 home runs, earning his first career Most Valuable Player Award. In Game 1 of the 1954 World Series against the Cleveland Indians, he achieved a moment of lasting significance by sprinting into the expansive center field of the Polo Grounds to make "The Catch"—a remarkable over-the-shoulder basket catch of a Vic Wertz drive that remains one of the most iconic defensive plays in the history of baseball.

His exceptional playmaking abilities contributed significantly to the Giants' historic sweep and their subsequent triumph in the World Series. Although this remained his solitary championship ring, his absolute peak was only just beginning.

That spectacular 1954 showcase launched an unyielding, 20-year run of dominance that made him a regular-season routine at the midsummer classic, earning an astonishing 24 All-Star selections through the 1971 season. At the plate, Mays possessed a telepathic eye for the strike zone and a thunderous right-handed swing, batting north of the .300 threshold nine separate times.

He declined to relinquish at-bats, utilizing his exceptional perception to draw walks at an extraordinary rate and surpassing the esteemed .400 on-base percentage threshold five times, while also securing two National League OBP efficiency titles.

As a pure power threat, he stood shoulder-to-shoulder with the greatest sluggers of all time. Mays captured four National League home run titles, blasting an unbelievable 646 of his 660 career home runs while with the Giants.

While a highly volatile RBI crown somehow eluded him due to situational lineup context, he remained the ultimate, high-leverage run producer, eclipsing the 100-RBI plateau ten separate times on his way to driving home 1,909 runs in a Giants uniform.

He brought home his second National League Most Valuable Player Award after a stellar 1965 season in which he hit a career-high 52 home runs. His consistent performance also earned him six more top-five finishes in the MVP voting.

Focusing solely on his offensive leaderboards provides only a partial view. Mays transformed the center field defensive position with a combination of exceptional closing speed, impeccable tracking, and a powerful throwing arm that intimidated opposing third-base coaches. In his extraordinary 1954 season, he led all National League position players in defensive bWAR and ranked in the top ten in seven other seasons, while leading the Senior Circuit in Total Zone Runs three times. Once the Gold Glove Award was introduced in 1957, Mays quickly amassed a record 12 consecutive Gold Gloves through 1968.

Additionally, his rapid and intense acceleration made him a dangerous threat on the basepaths well before the modern emphasis on speed in running games. From 1956 to 1959, he led the National League in stolen bases for four straight seasons, amassing 336 steals while playing for the Giants. He often executed double-steals, which frequently left opposing pitchers and catchers completely shaken.

Whether he was making a barehanded catch, sliding into third base with his cap flying off, or launching a 450-foot rocket into the seats, Mays infused the sport with a joyful, unadulterated passion that made him a beloved icon across two coasts. He served as the franchise’s ultimate structural bridge, guiding the organization through its seismic, landscape-shifting relocation from New York to San Francisco in 1958. As the club adjusted to the brutal, swirling winds of Candlestick Park, Mays remained the unshakable anchor, proving that his elite mechanics could overcome any environment.

Mays was traded to the New York Mets during the 1972 Season, where he unceremoniously ended his career, though he did help them win the 1973 Pennant.  He is still the all-time Giants leader in bWAR (154.5), Offensive bWAR (134.8), Runs Scored (2,011), Hits (3,187), and Home Runs (646).

Mays was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1979, his first year on the ballot.  San Francisco retired his number 24 in 1972 while he was still an active player, and he was later an inaugural member of the Giants’ Wall of Fame in 2008.

RIP: Stephan Bonnar

Mixed Martial Arts lost one of its favorite sons, as Stephan Bonnar, died of heart issues at the tender age of 45.

From Hammond, Indiana, Bonnar became a permanent fixture on the MMA scene when he made the Ultimate Fighter 1 Finals, in a unanimous decision loss to Forrest Griffin.  Despite his loss, Bonnar was so impressive in defeat that Dana White signed him to a UFC contract.

Bonnar went on to have a good career, but was never a champion in the UFC, though he would have many high-prominent fights, including losses to Rashad Evans, Jon Jones, Mark Coleman and Anderson Silva.  He retired in 2014 with a record of 15-9.

At UFC 162, Bonnar’s first fight with Griffin was inducted into the Fight Wing of the UFC Hall of Fame.

We here at Notinhalloffame.com would like to extend our condolences to the fans, friends and family of Stephan Bonnar.