Menu
A+ A A-
Committee Chairman

Committee Chairman

Kirk Buchner, "The Committee Chairman", is the owner and operator of the site.  Kirk can be contacted at [email protected] .

21. Kurt Warner

Kurt Warner's early fame was cemented by the sensational "Greatest Show on Turf" in St. Louis, but his resurgence in Arizona confirmed his Hall of Fame caliber. After a rocky transition year with the Giants in 2005, the experienced quarterback joined a Cardinals team desperately seeking stability at quarterback. What started as a bumpy, uncertain period in Arizona eventually evolved into one of the most remarkable second careers in football history.

His passing style depended on quick, instinctive pre-snap reads combined with exceptional pocket bravery. With elite processing speed and a gentle touch, Warner allowed routes to unfold downfield, trusting his arm and releasing the ball well before his receivers made their cuts. Supported by a dynamic receiving duo in Larry Fitzgerald and Anquan Boldin, he turned Arizona’s passing game into a potent vertical threat.

His early years in the desert involved a lot of instability. In 2005, injuries and inconsistent performance led him to share playing time with Josh McCown. The following season, in 2006, head coach Dennis Green shifted the offense to focus on rookie first-round pick Matt Leinart. Despite these changes, whenever Warner played, his precision was clear. After quietly regaining the starting role during the 2007 season and throwing 27 touchdown passes, he headed into the 2008 training camp in a true competition with Leinart.

Warner secured the starting role after camp and delivered a standout 2008 season. Rewinding the clock, he passed for 4,583 yards and 30 touchdowns, earning his fourth Pro Bowl selection and the 2008 Walter Payton NFL Man of the Year Award. During the 2008 playoffs, Warner achieved an incredible 1,261 passing yards and 11 TDs over four games, leading Arizona to its first Super Bowl appearance in franchise history. He carried that momentum into Super Bowl XLIII against the Steelers, passing for 377 yards and 3 touchdowns in a tight, exciting game. Warner's success continued in 2009 with another great season, throwing for 3,753 yards and returning the Cardinals to the postseason. Notably, he threw 5 touchdowns for 379 yards in a wild-card game against Green Bay, completing more touchdowns than incompletions (4).

After resolving all questions about his longevity, Warner chose to retire on his own terms following the 2009 season. His impressive five-year tenure with Arizona included 15,843 passing yards, 100 touchdowns, and a memorable postseason run that transformed the franchise. Warner was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2017, and we believe the 2008 season with the Cardinals was pivotal in establishing his Hall of Fame credentials. In 2014, Arizona also honored him by inducting him into their Ring of Honor.

20. Darnell Dockett

The defensive identity of the Arizona Cardinals during their historic Super Bowl XLIII run was forged in the disruptive energy of a third-round draft steal out of Florida State. Drafted 64th overall in the 2004 NFL Draft due to pre-draft character concerns that dropped his stock, Darnell Dockett arrived in the desert with a massive chip on his shoulder. He stepped onto the field and instantly evolved into one of the most explosive, penetration-style interior defensive linemen of his era.

Dockett had a quick, lethal first step that enabled him to penetrate gaps before offensive guards could establish their pass protection. Mainly functioning as an interior pass rusher, he used a combination of upper-body strength and aggressive hand techniques to collapse the pocket from the inside. Additionally, Dockett played with a relentless, fierce attitude that created an aggressive physical presence for the entire front seven.

His debut in 2004 made an immediate impression by securing a starting role and earning PFWA All-Rookie honors after recording 3.5 sacks and 39 tackles. His rise to elite status occurred in 2007, when he excelled at penetrating interior blocking schemes, achieving a career-high 9.0 sacks and 58 tackles, which led to his first Pro Bowl selection.

Dockett's standout moment came during the 2008 postseason on the sport's biggest stage. In Super Bowl XLIII against the Pittsburgh Steelers, he showcased an exceptional individual performance, tying the NFL Super Bowl record by sacking Ben Roethlisberger 3.0 times. His dominant play continued into the 2009 season, where he moved between defensive tackle and end, recording 7.0 sacks, earning Second-Team All-Pro honors and his second Pro Bowl invitation. He secured a third Pro Bowl selection in 2010, solidifying his role as a key interior defender early in the decade.

After missing the 2014 season due to a torn ACL, Dockett briefly joined division rival San Francisco in 2015. He was released before the start of the regular season and decided to return to Arizona, signing a ceremonial one-day contract in 2016 to officially retire as a lifelong member of the organization. Over ten seasons with the Cardinals, he accumulated 40.5 sacks, 459 tackles, 7 forced fumbles, and 4 interceptions across 158 games.

19. Ernie McMillan

Before the "Air Coryell" offenses of the mid-1970s captivated the football world, the trench work in St. Louis was anchored by a quiet, unheralded draft steal out of Illinois. Selected in the 13th round (176th overall) of the 1961 NFL Draft, Ernie McMillan arrived at training camp as a converted college tight end. The Cardinals quickly shifted his 6-foot-5, 275-pound frame to offensive tackle, unleashing a cerebral, technically sound blocker who would anchor the edge for fourteen consecutive seasons (1961–1974).

The mechanics of his play relied heavily on leverage, geometry, and exceptional lateral balance. In an era where pass protection was a hand-to-hand brawl against legendary edge rushers, McMillan excelled through calculated body control and precise angles. He was a textbook technician who mastered the art of mirroring pass rushers, once grading out at a staggering 96 percent efficiency on pass blocks across a single season. His endurance was equally remarkable; after taking over as the full-time starter in his second year, he set a franchise record by starting 162 consecutive games without missing a single contest due to injury over his first twelve seasons.

In a testament to his selflessness and leadership, McMillan willingly moved from his longtime right tackle slot to left tackle late in his St. Louis tenure to accommodate the rise of young star Dan Dierdorf. That positional sacrifice allowed the Cardinals to field one of the most formidable tackle tandems in league history. After a final 1974 season in St. Louis where he helped secure a division title, he finished his career with a brief stint in Green Bay in 1975, retiring with 190 career regular-season games.

18. Marshall Goldberg

Marshall Goldberg, a two-time consensus All-American and Heisman Trophy finalist under Jock Sutherland at Pitt, became a national star when the Chicago Cardinals picked him in the 1939 NFL Draft's second round. As one of the earliest notable Jewish superstars in pro football, Goldberg's unique blend of backfield strength, return speed, and defensive savvy quickly boosted the team's competitiveness.

Goldberg had a low, powerful running style that made him effective between the tackles, combined with the quick acceleration of a track athlete. His versatility enabled him to play as a fullback, halfback, kick returner, and safety effortlessly. On defense, his quick decision-making and knack for turnovers made him a persistent threat to intercept passes from opponents, while his open-field tackling often stopped large plays in their tracks.

His multi-phase versatility peaked during the 1941 season. Goldberg delivered an impressive single-season performance, rushing for 427 yards, catching passes for 313 yards, and leading the NFL with 290 kickoff return yards. His total of 1,236 all-purpose yards topped the league, earning him a Pro Bowl spot and All-Pro honors. Not satisfied with offensive dominance alone, Goldberg also excelled on defense, tying for the league lead with 7 interceptions. He carried this exceptional energy into 1942, finishing fifth in all-purpose yards and continuing to excel in the secondary.

During his prime, Goldberg paused his football career to serve in the U.S. Navy for two years in the South Pacific during World War II. After returning to Chicago in 1946, he chose to play primarily as a safety to support the Cardinals' renowned "Dream Backfield,” which included Charley Trippi, Paul Christman, Elmer Angsman, and Pat Harder. His unselfish switch to safety became the defensive cornerstone of the memorable 1947 season, ending with a thrilling victory over the Philadelphia Eagles that secured the franchise's only NFL Championship to date.

Goldberg played one more season before calling it a career. He recorded 1,644 rushing yards, 775 receiving yards, 1,083 return yards, and 19 interceptions across 77 regular-season games. The Cardinals enshrined Goldberg into their Ring of Honor in 2006.