Cecil Cooper was a really good baseball player though it seemed that only people in Milwaukee were aware of it! 

Ryan Braun was labeled as a five-tool player before he debuted with the Milwaukee Brewers and with the exception of average defense, it is safe to say he achieved that expectation.  Braun would win the National League Rookie of the Year in 2007 and four years later won the coveted MVP Award.  The slugger would also capture the Home Run Title and to date has represented the Brewers in six All-Star Games.  Five Slugging Titles and two OPS Titles are also in Braun’s trophy case.

Inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in his first year of eligibility, Paul Molitor was with the Blue Brew Crew for the first fifteen of his twenty-one seasons in Major League Baseball.  One of the most complete hitters of the game, Molitor had seven seasons where he batted over .300, had moderate power numbers (160 Home Runs as a Brewer) and would eight-time exceed 30 Stolen Bases. 

As of this writing, this decision was not very hard.

Robin Yount never left the Milwaukee Brewers and for many fans in Wisconsin, the former Shortstop is the greatest baseball player that ever existed for the Milwaukee Brewers.