Print this page

The Pro Football Hall of Fame Revisited Project: 2004 Semi-Final VOTE

21 Nov
2026
Not in Hall of Fame

2004 SEMI-FINAL RESULTS:

Thank you for your participation in the Pro Football Hall of Fame Revisited Project. If you are unaware of what that is, we acted like the PFHOF had its first class in January 1946.

We have completed the years up to 2003.

For “2004,” a Preliminary Vote with nearly 100 players whose playing career ended by 1998. We also follow the structure in which players have 20 years of eligibility, and if they do not make it into the Hall, they are relegated to the Senior Pool.

Each voter was asked to select 25 names from the preliminary list, and the top 25 vote-getters were named Semi-Finalists.

A week later, the voters were asked to pick 15 names from the 25 Semi-Finalists, and next week, they will choose five from the remaining 15. We will continue this process every week until we catch up to the current year.

30 votes were cast, with the top 15 advancing.

This is for the “Modern Era”

Bold indicates they advanced to the Finals: 

Player

Year of Eligibility

Vote Total

John Elway QB

1

29

Barry Sanders RB

1

29

Richard Dent DE

2

26

George Kunz T

19

24

Karl Mecklenburg LB

5

22

Joe Klecko DE-NT

11

20

Fred Dean DE

14

19

Harry Carson LB

11

19

Ken Riley DB

16

16

Todd Christensen TE

11

15

Jim Marshall DE

20

14

Deron Cherry DB

8

14

Mark Gastineau DE

11

14

Steve McMichael DT

5

13

Sam Mills LB

2

13

Albert Lewis DB

1

13

Pat Swilling LB-DE

1

13

Russ Francis TE

11

12

Stanley Morgan WR

9

12

Harold Carmichael WR

15

11

Clay Matthews Jr. LB

3

11

Jimbo Covert T

9

10

Mike Kenn T

5

10

Harold Jackson WR

16

8

Steve Tasker ST

2

8

Wilber Marshall LB

4

7

This is for the “Senior Era”

*Bold indicates they advanced to the Finals:

Player

Year of Eligibility

Vote Total

Winston Hill T

2

20

Walt Sweeney G

4

19

Alan Ameche FB

19

18

Andy Russell LB

2

13

Billy Wilson E

19

7

None of the Above

 

1

This is for the “Coaches/Contributors Era”

*Bold indicates they advanced to the Finals:

Nominee

Year of Eligibility

Vote Total

COACH: Jimmy Johnson

3

20

COACH: Tom Flores

7

16

EXEC: Bobby Beathard

2

15

EXECUTIVE: George Young

7

12

TV EXECUTIVE: Roone Arledge

18

10

None of the Above

 

3

We will post the Class of 2004 Pro Football Hall of Fame Revisited Project next Saturday.

Thank you to all who contributed. If you want to be part of this project, please let us know!

Comments powered by CComment