45. Harry Lumley

Harry Lumley had already made history, when in 1944, at the age of 17, he became the youngest (and still is), Goalie to play in the NHL when he suited up for the Rangers.  Later, he won a Stanley Cup with Detroit, though was traded to Chicago in favor of Terry Sawchuk.  A few years later, Lumley was dealt again, this time to Toronto, where he had his best period in terms of individual performance.

The Leafs at this stage were not world-beaters, but Lumley was their bright spot.  He won the Vezina in 1953-54, where he also was named a First Team All-Star.  For the first time in his career, Lumley led the NHL in GAA (1.86) and was fifth in Hart voting.  He was as good the year after, again winning the GAA Title (1.91) and again earned First Team All-Star honors.  Lumley was also the runner-up for the Hart Trophy. 

After another season in Toronto, Lumley was traded back to Chicago, where he refused to report.  He was eventually traded to Boston, where he would finish his career.

Lumley was chosen for the Hockey Hall of Fame in 1980.