Mogilny did not have the potency that landed him 76 Goals as a Buffalo Sabre in 1992-93, but his offense helped the Devils win the 2000 Stanley Cup, and the year after, he had 43 Goals, his last 40-plus year. He signed with Toronto as a Free Agent in 2000 but returned in 2005, for his final NHL season.
As a Devil, he only played 121 Games, averaging .94 a Game.