Menu
A+ A A-
Committee Chairman

Committee Chairman

Kirk Buchner, "The Committee Chairman", is the owner and operator of the site.  Kirk can be contacted at [email protected] .

Should Philip Rivers be a Hall of Famer?

The career of Philip Rivers will be a furious debate for Hall of Fame voters when the quarterback becomes eligible in the 2025 class. Rivers never won a Super Bowl or even played in one, but he was one of the finest quarterbacks of his generation.

Over a 17-year career with the San Diego/Los Angeles Chargers and the Indianapolis Colts, Rivers threw for 63,440 passing yards along with 421 touchdowns to 209 interceptions. He holds two NFL records with the most consecutive completions in a game with 25, and the most games in a row with a passer rating over 120.

Rivers is a Chargers’ legend and arguably their greatest player alongside LaDainian Tomlinson. No player appeared in more games or won more games for the franchise than Rivers. He also enjoyed one stellar season for the Colts, guiding them back to the post-season. Rivers left both the Chargers and Colts in strong positions in the AFC Conference with quarterbacks Justin Herbert and Carson Wentz respectively.

The Chargers are backed in the NFL odds from Betfair at 9/1 to win the AFC Conference in the 2021 season and appear in their first Super Bowl in 27 seasons. Los Angeles have an early advantage over their rivals in the AFC West division and are poised to return to the post-season for the first time in three years, therefore, tracking their progress in the NFL betting tips may be worthwhile this term. 

For all Rivers’ achievements, his inability to drag the franchise into the title game will be a stain on his legacy. It is why he may miss out on the Hall of Fame. Rivers could be established alongside other quality passers of his generation such as Tony Romo in the hall of very good rather than the elite category. The Chargers should have reached the Super Bowl in the 2006 campaign, boasting the best record in the AFC and an abundance of talent at their disposal.

However, he and his high-powered offense choked under the pressure, suffering a one-and-done defeat to the New England Patriots. The same Patriots haunted the Chargers in the following season. Rivers’ legacy was enhanced by his performance as he played on a torn ACL and battled 60 minutes against the unbeaten New England outfit, losing 21-12 even without Tomlinson who left the contest in the first quarter.

After those near misses, head coach Marty Schottenheimer was fired and the Chargers failed to mount another significant run during Rivers’ tenure. He remained on point during the regular season and formed excellent rapports with Vincent Jackson, Keenan Allen and most importantly of all Antonio Gates. However, when it came to the clutch, Rivers was unable to rise to the occasion and drag his team through in the playoffs.

Unfortunately for him and the Chargers, they played in the era of Brady, Peyton Manning and Ben Roethlisberger, who had a monopoly on Super Bowl appearances for their respective franchises in the AFC Conference. Those players rightfully are and will belong in the Hall of Fame.

Had the breaks gone another way or had he excelled in the fourth quarter Rivers may have had the credentials to push a claim through to Canton in the mould of Eli Manning. However, those post-season performances will count against his bid. Therefore, it would be very surprising to see him donning the gold jacket come 2025.

43. Bill Houlder

Beginning his NHL career in 1987 with the Washington Capitals, Defenseman Bill Houlder would later play for Buffalo, Anaheim, St. Louis, and Tampa Bay, before joining Nashville early in the 1999/00 Season after being selected off of the Waiver Draft.

Houlder was in his early 30s by this time and did not have the same offensive capability, but the Defenseman was still a savvy player and still provided value to a young team.  Houlder played until the end of the 2002/03 Season, scoring 44 Points over 302 Games with the Predators.

42. Sergei Kostitsyn

Kostitsyn looked to be traded out, and he got it when he was sent packing to Nashville in 2010.

Kostitsyn responded well in his first year in Music City, producing what would be a career-high 50 Points and leading the NHL in Shot Percentage (24.7).  It looked like he turned it around, but it was not to be, as he slipped to 43 Points and plummeted to 15 Points in 46 Games in 2012/13.  Kostitsyn and the Predators agreed to part ways following the season's end, and he returned to Russia to play in the KHL.  Kostitsyn could have had a better and much longer career in North America, but his heart was never in it, and he was much happier in Russia, but on a team as young as Nashville, Kostitsyn is worthy of being on this list.

33. Colton Sissons

As of this writing, Center Colton Sissons has played his entire NHL career with the Nashville Predators, a team he debuted for in 2013.  

Sissons is a lower line Center who is mainly used on the grinding line, which has worked well for Nashville, but he is capable of lighting the lamp, as shown by his hat trick that won the Predators the deciding game in the 2017 Western Conference Final, and is coming off of his second 30 Point year.

Currently, Sissons has collected 165 Points with a Plus/Minus of +36.